shade or urgal

Shade......there like an elf..........fast speed......strong in magic..........a shade could kill like 900 kull before being slain himself.

I said a Shade as well.

Ofcourse it's shade! shade can manipulate even a kull-urgal.. he's strong.. Maybe the question should be: which one more powerful, Shade or Ra'zac??

I still say shade, he is. But if the question is Shade vs. mother of ra'zac, u know with the wings and magic and speed and anything... That one, i can't answer

A shade would win for her exact reasons above this post

Maybe if the shade was not as strong as Durza, then maybe if the Urgals had a complete army against the shade they could maybe win. It only requires one person anyway to strike in th heart of the shade.

even if there was a whole army the shade would still win unless there was a rider there then thats a different story all together

even razac vs shade the shade would win i mean razac cant use magic

well it could all depend on luck in the end

well dont forget the razac can move fast but a shade would most likly move faster, and the razac are good with swords and can go places fast so in the end it could be ethier one of them its a great matchup

I say Urgal!!!! just cause they are cool, and you know theres never just one

Shade all the way!!!!!

Are you messed up in the head??!! A shade would win!!

a shade would win

YA I HAVE SOMEONE WHO AGREES WITH ME!!!!!!!

I forgot that a shade is not always durza -- but we never seen any shade beside durza at this series, haven't we? still shade it is...

Everyone else here agrees with you. But whose to say Durza wasnt the most powerful shade, maybe all others are just slightly more powerful than humans, besides i like to be the oddball

a shde would win (i said this in a repetitive monotone voice)

i say a shade would win cuz durza already proved that in the first book, when he killed them in the beginning and when he took control of that whole army of urgals in the end

this doesnt mean i like shades...

Kinda like louis said, if it was a hole army if Urgals then the Urgals would win. But then again Shades are really powerful they can use magic and stuff. I'm impartial

i vote for shade

Shade just looks cool

definitly shade

Shade definetly, compared to a rider a shade might just be like killing an ant but to an urgal it take at least 1000 to come close to his heart

shades are a lot stronger because they can kill about 100000 urgals without getting touched

Ya but if u compare them to ther Spellcasters there not that great there about middle I bet durza was one of the weak ones

Ya but if u compare them to ther Spellcasters there not that great there about middle I bet durza was one of the weak ones

no he was a stronger one and he was killed

Really, oh

shade because they can just wipe a human clean off the map

ill say its a shade

yup

did u read the book ya idiot?

Yep I agree, Shade!

shades could beat Ra'zac cos their breath won't effect him

Words of wisdom. A Shade would win.

hmmmmmmmmmm

i say shade....more powerful

shades are definitely better, but not....oh wat's his name again? the one that almost killed eragon. well anyways, that shade was a retard. who can beat a dragon rider anyways?

i think that a shade could kill 300 ugrla befor he was killed and 100 kull befor he was slain (but also remeamber that only 3 people have survived a shade

the idea that a urgal could beat a shade is laughable
The shade would win in about a second.

shade. Shades are just better. Evil...but better.
edit: remember in the prologue(?) of the first book when Durza slew like 9 Urgals in like 1 second?

yep thats the event I was thinking of

a shade could beat 5 urgals by them self

shade, of course.

o my god defenetly a shade

shade, caterpillar, like an urgal could killl one

That's too easy, of course a shade!

i think the question should be:

who would win, a shade, or 100 urgals

a shade definately as it has magic, an urgal is basicly a brain dead human

This is a stupid question -.- obviously a shade would win...

unless the Shade was poisined and weaked while sleeping and the urgal creapt up and stabbed him in the heart, but do shades even sleep?

Shade. Mmmm.... I don't know..... If the Urgal uses trickery.... Nah... Urgal can't win. Shade will probably smell it or hear it nearby.

durza killed the urgals in the prologue to eragon

shade...an urgal wouldn't even know how to slay a shade so shade could kill a billion of them before one of them figured out how to kill him...

soo shade. in the prologue(sp?) of eragon, the shade killed some of them with energy palms from his hand.