If you go to amazon.com and look up the book The Element Encyclopedia of Witchcraft: The Complete A-Z for the Entire Magical World and you look at the picture of the front of the book it looks kinda like the Menoa tree and look what's between the roots. Am I just paranoid or is that a coindence?

ill check it out

What is so speacle about that?

mayby CP copied from that self conciously...or mayby coincidence

(says this sarcastically) Or maybe cp is a witch

lmao he makes us all read it...with MAGIC

Is that what menoa tree looks like?? Beautiful! Enchanted! Between the roots, is that an orc? Hmm...
weird... *thinking*
Why don't we ask CP?? Maybe he's in the forum to..! (Helloo... CP.....!!??)

FYI: Magick is a very very powerful sorce that I know how to use. So be wise about it because it can turn its back on you.

yes, it is. it happens everytime in my country. For example, if you want to "curse" me you can go to a paranormal guy, you pay and he will send me the curse. Soon after that i will bear some sickness no doctors in the world could detect. The only way is to came to another paranormal to break the curse... My friend hade xperienced this curse once, she said when she was "healed" by the paranormal guy, there's nothing logical in it... At the time she was asked, did she want to gave back the curse to the sender? if she's agreed so the curse will fly back against its master..

It is happening here.

now what country would that be

I wouldn't use my magick against anybody here anyways, unless I want to kill myself because I doubt if even Galbortorix himself would be able to go through a dimension and live. So you people are in luck. Plus why waste it on you people when I can save it for Galbortorix.

well that was rude makes me mad

An egg? Is the secret weapon under the menoa tree another dragon egg? that would be sooooo cool!

Youd think someone who lived there could spell Galbatorix. It is a fictional world, that you DO NOT live in, you are fooling nobody. I think your either a lonely child or had one too many pills this morning.

well back to the topic.

is there even such thing as magic?

Well I'm sorry Mr. Superior that my spelling isn't exactly correct. I was only taught once how to read by Brom but then I had to leave so I really had nothing to practice on.

can i hurt you? just a little? Did they have internet in aleagasia?

Hmm... what country indeed


what is it with you and her??

lol forget it fath kats not in eragons world...shes in a world of her oun... thinking shes in eragons world trust me.. she aint the only person iv seen that has "tried" to fool ppl in thinking that she is there its just plain old REALITY nothing ever has or will happen that is "magical" and how could you? This story was wrtien hardly a year an a half ago must mean ur like 2...

there is an egg under the tree... i hope that that's the weopen

Its a strange thing about that but. mybe it is true. Who knows?

I highly doubt it, but a creative idea!

ooh! ooh! ooh!
what if that is the third egg???
after all, arya lives in du weldenvarden, and she helped with Saphira's egg.

Then why hasn't it hatched yet? Millions upon Millions of elves passed it at the festival... maybe the next rider will be a human...

Well if it is an egg, that would be cool!

Guys quit double posts!

ya, an egg under the menona tree. great idea, very creative.

For an egg to hatch you must have direct contact with it. You must touch it not just walk past it because the dragon inside can't tell if you're the one if you just walk past.

Reading the book tells us this, again you are prooving nothing but your stupidity

*looks at Glenwing as he totally pwns katerna* Heh.


Maybe Brom or some0one DID manage to get the third egg (besides Saphira and Thorn), and it was kept secret because they didn't want to reveal to Galby that it was hidden in Du Weldenvarden. Maybe they only wanted to take the risk of only one egg getting stolen as Arya transported it back and forth. Or MAYBE the elves are keeping it secret because they want to have a rider for their own race. Hm. Later.

mayb glaedrs a haemaphrodite and decided 2 hav it on wit himself, and he hid the egg under the tree. or mayb the eragon series has nuffin 2 do wit that book on amazon?

I don't get what's so great about that book on amazon, it could be any old tree on the cover with something white in it. I suppose it was an ok idea though.

i think ur totally rite

yea, i dont think that tree is big enough to be the menona but nice try though

menoa tree is huge not small and Glaedr is not a hermaphrodite

You guys are scaring me!!!!!!! wahhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh momie these guys are crazy *looks at everyone* uh...... My retarted twin hes escaped again..... your not buying this are you????????*everyone shakes head* grrr

Glenwing and katrena YOU GUYS H8 EACHOTHER APERANTLY and Grimly there could be magic im not saying its real it could be there. but katrena thinks she comes from alsaiga{sp} and had the sam undergoing and life as eargon *looks at katrena*. but it could be there you know like mericales and stuff...................

all i see is a frog

the cover had a tree with a stone inbetween its roots so what

it's totally obviously not the menona tree

hey, remeber when nari and eragon are having the discussion on the way to Duweldervarden... well i believe that what he said is true and the blood of royalty flows through palancar vally, so roran is proably royalty, and will become the next rider or will be chosen by the people to be a monarch for the goverment,,, JUST A THOUGHT

idk nething bout it... but it is super cool!
adios

i think roran will kill the ra'zac... do u???

my god you mean that the egg is in the roots of the menowa tree!!

pft... I don't think so somehow! That's a completely different book anyway, nothing to do with eragon!

an dragon egg cant be under the menoa tree cos solembun said when the time comes YOU will need a wepon eragon cant have 2 dragons

Ann egg? A frog or is it a toad? I bet Angela would find it interesting.

some Frogs are Toads but all toads are frogs

some Frogs are Toads but all toads are frogs

you guys re totally confusing me with the whole frog toads thing....when i read the book i was like wha and didnt get and i still dont get it!!!

it's simple but
some all
frogs toads
are are
toads frogs
see

toads don't exist

I think this was just a word play of CP to introduce the character of Angela as a controversial, unique, fun, and a "I don't care what people think of me" person. And if you think of it, her role in the book is funny, important and yet ands a kind of twist in everything she does. So don't worry if frogs or toads exists.

she is always happy and cheery
and she adores fungi
she is a good warrior
she is good at guessing riddles
she can cast spells
she can tell the future

Angela is a wonderful Character, and the girl casted for her role is perfect. She exactly the "Angela" I had pictured in my mind!

wow thats ...wierd

i don't believe it, seriously not sarcastic

I really like the people that were casted for the film. But I think we are out of topic again. Firetongue and Glenwing are so going to kick us out.

oh i was talking about the tree thing. oh my gosh, i hope this topic is about the tree thing!!

Actually it is closely related, so we are fine!!

That is SO not the Menoa tree-besides, it doesn't even look like an egg.

About the egg: that is way to small to be a dragon egg. It looks like a chicken egg, and that might be what it is because the egg might be refering to something in the book.

Remember: this book has absolutely nothing to do with Eragon in any way!!

well, if you wanna believe in it... i think that it is your imagination that spuns your thoughts around your head...

well for the menoa tree, maybe CP used it as an example to create the tree...

paranoid. but, maybe thats why its, "one boy, two dragons"

DUDE, ITS A FREAKING FROG!! WUTS SO AWESOOME ABOUT THAT?

They weren't talkin' about the frog they were talking about the egg!!!

haha thats funny the whole frog thing and the tree and the egg they al have to do with the books first the frog has to do with angela trying to prove toads dont exist and the tree is like the menoa tree and the egg is obvious lol

Yeah