Do you think tha Eragon could revive Brom?If he finds and use the enerdy of the sword of oromis and the enrgy of the Aren i think tha he coul achieve it.Also i believe that this s a good idea beacuse Brom is in the diamond tomb so he is not disintegrated or something...what do you think?

What if he or enyone else kill another person in order to revive a dead?Could this happen?

for that part cp might and brom's life wasn't that depressing

no there had to be some things he liked like eragon.

you said all the bad things and left out the good brom might of had somethings he liked that weren't in the books.

just cause cp didn't say it good mean that there wasn't anything

cool someone agrees with me

brom life wasn't as bad as you said that why i did the smilie i wasn't laughing at his life.

what did brom say? did he say his life was as bad as evry oneelse said?

You say so,and when you say so everyone else must shut it right?In my opinion Brom would want to live.Especially now that he can have son.What kind of father doesn't want to see his son fighting an evil king or bringing his father from the dead?Do you really think that eragon can't replace Saphira's and selene's death to brom?He definetly can in my opinion.And Brom would be so proud of him.

yeah he got used to it and eragon the fall of galby the resurface of the riders would replace saphira1 and selene who have been dead a long time and who is to say eragon can't bring them back either

if eragon can bring back brom he can bring back saphira1 and selena

and vagabond wasn't that rude not as rude as when you said that i was laughing at how bad brom's life was

Excuse but you are telling me that you had a dragon,he died,and now you understand Brom?Are you serious?
And,believe me i wasn't rude at all,but you can't possibly think that you can talk to people in that way and no one should talk tou you like this.
One last thing,if you think that my english are bad you are right,but go learn greek first and then you can criticise me as much time as you like.

i agree with all vagabond said and please only coment on my english enless you have no clue what i am saying and politly ask

Umm, no need to be rude or mean to any of the other users and why are you soo toucy on the topic, did you loose your dragon?
Anyway I'm not sure if Brom will return or if he would connect with Eragon via dreams or visions.

i like the idea of brom in the dreams

1. No, I learned this information from the books. If you had read them then you would know how hard it is to lose a dragon. It is described and several examples are given and Oromis talks about how hard it was for Brom and several other people talk about Brom's life. After he lost his dragon a lot of bad things did happen and one of the only good things was finding Selena. Like I have said several times before, I never said everything in his life was bad. I said most of things were.

2. Bringing Dragons back from the dead is different and a lot harder than bringing a human. They have different insides, organs, skin, and many other different things besides the fact the are a multitude of times larger than humans.

3. If your location said Greece instead of 'The middle of nowhere' than I would know that English isn't your first language but since you didn't I don't take back what I said. That's your fault, not mine.

4. Jaythe, I said it was cruel because you commented that his life wasn't that depressing, meaning that you knew it was and then put a laughing smiley face after it.

5. I have asked you, Jaythe. You never do, that's why I'm saying it again.

i say my posts clealy enough and smilies are my way of showing that i am not mad even if it is a evil smilie

you haven't said any thing about saphira12 said a dream brom

this my sound wierd but the people in the books do not know evrything

and for whatever his reasons cp might wait till book 4 you did not write the books

if you didn't write the books then don't act like you did


people can be wrong more people have been wrong then there are people in alagisea the romans thought that space went around earth, people thought earth was flat, people thought that math was fun

it was a joke about the math and i edited the post

Actually i made a hread a thread ,when i first signed in the forum,in the introduce yourself subforum.You could read it where i say a lot basic things about myself.I'm so sorry that i haven't wrote my real location,but...wait a minute,more than 200 members haven't wrote their real location either,i suppose it is located in their "introduce yourself"threads.Finally i have readen the inheritance circle twice,and i believe that i know how Brom feel's,but now a lot of time has passed and the pain in Brom as faded.Also he has his son,who is also a dragon rider with a dragon named saphira and Brom will surely be proud for him.e will be more prod if his son managed to revive him,proving that he can achieve something that other's can't

vagabond has a good piont and can you please answer this one gnomensigh?

yes and someone who read it once could know it better than someone who read it 50 4 times doesn't mean you know more about than any one else

can't you read it says fifty not five hundred

Jaythe means: Yes, and someone who read it once could know it better than someone who read it 50 times. 4 times doesn't mean you know more about it than any one else.

the fifty was like this 50. the four wasn't


eragon+arya: thanks

Your welcome.
No matter how many times I've read the books, I still think Brom should be brought back.

I cannot understand this.
Eragon:Hey,Brom,look at me.I ressurected you.Isn't it awesome?I'm a very powerfull mage
Brom:No you are not.You are an idiot.Who told you that i want to live?
That's the silliest thing i have ever heard.It's also silly to argue abou how many times someone has read the book.Jaythe_wise knew very well what he was saying...

vagabond has a good point and how he said it made me laugh .

if it failed if it did brom would still be dead

And not o mention that Brom is in a diamond tomb and his cells and his muscles can't be disintegrated...

ooohhh, yes it is based on real life there are elves urgals magic knurlan dragons just like real life

Of course it is.Yesterday i was going to a supermarket to buy some eggs,and i saw an urgal in my way.He told me he was going to buy eggs too.The supermarket was really crowded with dwarves and some elves.Two of them started a fight so the police came.I ran quickly home with the eggs only to find a dragon in my garage...

It is. Yester day when I went to ballet the class full of danceing elves. After class I flew home on my dragon and saw urgals and dwarves fighting over a gas pump.

You guys are hilarious.

Anyway, I am not sure what to think about the entire topic of Brom returning from the dead. The most LIKELY person to return is Oromis and that is still a shaky turnout.

she say something like she's just saying her opinion e+a

I'm going to lock this until everybody has a breather.