In Nar Hazhogs memories it said he grew up in a village in the spine
if urgals lived in the spine eragon should know as he is the only person who would go deep into it
What do you think about this

Well, the spine runs down most of Alagaesia. Eragon only went in the bits round Carvahall. It's interesting to know that there are Urgal villages in the Spine though, maybe he will find one.

also i was wondering how did galby lose half his army in the spine

Maybe they fell down the Igualda falls like Sloan's wife? Maybe a magic user or two were hiding there? Maybe it was before he made an allegiance with the urgals, and they killed them?

i doubt 1000 men found falls down hole

Maybe they were all marching in a long line, and the first one falls, and grabs the next one, who grabs the next one and half the army ends up falling down!

maybe we will find out in brom's book

Or in Empire.

wait i remenber
in eragon urgals went to loads of villages didn't they but why didn't cavurhal get invaded as its right next to the spine and the urgals should at least go into therinsford

Well they were only destroying those villages because they happened to be along the path to the Hadarac, right? Carvahall wouldn't have been in the way.

yes i agree but Therinsford is in the way of he hadarac and the spine

I am going with this theory, but the imge of the army falling down in a hole (like the domino effect) is very amusing. Thanks, I needed a good laugh!

[I apologize to you all for double-posting. My computer was giving a hard time. This is the second one I spot. Well, the 1st one really, Eragon the first Elf pointed out the first one.

u double posted

AHHHH, did you see my apology? I would have deleted it if I could, but unfortunately it does not appear on the upper right hand corner are "quote" "edit" and "report." Besides it is the only time it has happened. Look up all my posts. I tried to fix it!!

youve could edited it

http://www.squidoo.com/inheritance/ << at this link their is a pretty good theory on how he lost his army.. annibee found it an made a new topic on it.. but check it out

probly becase rember the book sayed the spine is very unknwn and dangers are vast
many dont live thur it

ya maybe but read the theory on how they think it happened.. its pretty good

but he did, didnt he? !6,000 must have been most of the rest of his army

Hmm...I like this thought and I'll stick to it. Maybe Eragon will find some villages or something...but I say he better be wary and careful though...Urgals can be rather aggressive and dangerous. Not that he couldn't handle them but still. And yeah the Spine is huge...I don't think he travelled all through it...it would have taken him days maybe less, who knows. I wonder though how many villages there could be in the Spine. Hmm...