downs:

1 no solumbum

2 angela's.... weird

3 no twins

4 no katrina

5 roran leaves early to serve in the army

6 saphira's voice is stupid

7 it's like 3 days long

8 it never shows the hadarack desert

9 brom is killed in gil'ead when durza trys to kill eragon

10 the razak don't look like they're supposed to

11 eragon and brom kill the razak the first time they see them

12 saphira learns to breath fire right before the battle

13 eragon shoots durza inbetween his eyes instead of murtagh

14 eragon never gets his scar

15 it never says that hrothgar is a dwarf

16 it never says hrothgar is king

17 arya has blond hair

18 arya has curved ears

19 arya appears to eragon in multiple dreams

20 there is no lake in front of farthen dur

21 there is no farthen dur. the varden's hideout is inbetween mountains

22 there is no orik

23 you never hear the morning sage

24 they never go to tearm

25 eragon never gets captured

26 brom and eragon only spar once

27 murtagh and eragon never spar

28 murtagh doesn't gain trust by the varden until an urgal breaks into his cell and then he comes out and kills urgals

29 brom doesn't talk with eragon about the riders before they leave carvahal

30 he's only in the varden's hideout for 1 night

31 hrothgar and ajihad meet him as soon as he enters their little cave thing

32 there is no isidar mithrim

33 brom hides his gedway ignarsia under his sleeve

34 eragon finds out that brom is a rider on his own

35 zarok looks like it's painted

36 it's only like 1 hour long

37 there is no cadock or snowfire, they just have two random horses

38 arya is awake when she is rescued and when brom dies

39 brom never told eragon about the seven words

40 eragon never found out about the rock of curuthin or the weapon under the manoa tree

41 eragon is blond

42 saphira grows up instantly (literaly)

43 there are only like 2 archers

44 murtagh's cell is just a wooden cage

45 it says murtagh is the son of morzan, but it never says who morzan is

46 durza is riding this weird shadow dragon thing

47 eragon stabs durza while they are falling from the sky

48 saphira almost dies

49 arya returns to elesmera imidiatly after the battle

50 the razak don't burn down eragon's house, brom does!


ups:

1. both dragon's animations look cool (it shows shruikan)

2. saphira is cute when she's a baby

I thought that Saphia's voice was okay, and the actors did a good job. But I agree with you with everthing else!!!

I agree eapset brom toled that morzan was a dragon rider who joined galbatorix and he killed him so he sad who he was but nott wery well

-and saphira looks like my dog whene she is a baby

-eragon didint ask meany questions

They didn't protrey Brom and Eragon as in the books. Eragon is annoying and ask to many questions while Brom is annoyed by him and seem not to willing to answer the questions. In the movie, Brom seem happy to answer the questions. It's just plain wrong.

I have to agree baby Saphira is so so so cute..... but the flight where she grew up from a young dragon to a big dragon is just plain weird.

I agree with everything you have said. And I have to say that it is sad that I can still think of other things that were wrong too!
Like Saphira names herself?
Did any of their lines come from the book?
And so on and so on....

At least they buried Brom somewhat like they did in the book. But it looked more like plain glass and had no engraving.

Roran left so he didn't have to go to the army.

urm no offence but.. ANGELA IS WIERD! lol she is but shes funny. and saphira is amazin and the twins i think werent seen but they were meant to be init i cnt remeber. 3 days long??? wat?? they do skip days. the raz'zac are hard to portray because everyone has different views on it. u can tell hrogther is a dwarf because he is small. ok this is just my view lol. tho i aggree and plus u mist the fact that he doesnt get the cut across the back by durza.

they're not going to even be able to make eldest. no one will see it so they'll go out of buissnus

lol yeah its true

i think the movie was fine. i also think that itd be a heartbreaker if they didnt make Eldest. The only thing i was upset with fully was that they blew through the book in a hurry.

it wasnt like the book. they couldnt blow through it

no no i mean the day and night went by really fast.

remeber tho cp played no part in the making of the film so nothing we can do. eldest can still be done by da way coz murtagh can be captured and stuff like dat. the twins i still rekon have been cast coz ive seen the picture nd stuff .

was wrong bout twins it was a misread soz lol

You know, the most amazing "up" of the whole film- the way they let Brom die. I hate to admit it, but that one bit was better than how CP himself did it. I loved it- Saphira goes "let him die with honour, as a rider" or something along those lines, and he dies riding Saphira! I just thought that was such a good scene. Apart from that, the book was obviously a lot better than the film, but I still liked the film. I mean, sure, they missed a LOT of things out, but I watched it as a good film, rather than comparing it to to book all the way through. If you spend the whole time scrutinizing it for what they did or didn't do, it just doesn't make it an enjoyable experience at all.

i TOTALLY agree yay someone does!! lol only jkn!!!
i nearly cried wen brom died it was so sad!