why, not where to

Why? It's quite simple. Eragon is going to leave Alagaesia forever because he is going to leave Alagaesia to go look for a mate for Saphira (as he promised to in Eldest), and while he is there, he is going to fall in love with someone, and they are never going to leave. THE END. HALLELUJAH and good night.

yay, finally someone who agrees with my theory. ive like posted it up in three different locations and no one likes it.


but i like your theory as well.

ok. why do people EVER leave places on giant ships with tons of elves? Think about it.

idk. maybe...hmmmmmmmm...these are the things that only CP knows.

*sits down to meditate*

nope, not getting a signal. oh, well.

Thorn and Saphira??? blech. that's disgusting. Thorn is like so evil. and besides, i think he's going to die in the final battle, along with Murtagh.

i think that the elves will be forced to leave and eragon arya saphira and other dragon will leave with them and the person cring on the beach is roran who cant leave with them becase hes human

the elves are so powerful they wont ever have to leave, even if the world was ending.

okay. i like the part about roran ruling. ive posted that on another topic but i guess to put it on this one. as for the rest it, i agree that maybe the third egg will hatch (which goes against everything ive posted in another topic), but i really doubt its going to be arya. i mean, arya is just so old, she has more wisdom, and shes just strange. it makes no sense. but i like it.

Ok so I think it is pretty obvious why Eragorn will leave...well I have two theories actually.

1) Arya continues to avoid Eragon's advances through out the book until she 'finds a green male dragon' (not sure if true or not and do not want to know, I am doing my best not to spoild the book for myself) Eventaully Saphira and this new young buck mate and the residing sexual attraction brings Eragon and Arya together at last. Arya was disgruntled about the pairing until she realises shes pregnent. At the end of the book CP will create a knock off of LOTR and have the "age of elves and dwarves end, as the age of men comes" Then the elves shall leave the shores and go back to wherever it is they came from. (It is said that the dwarves where there before the elves so it stands to reason the elves would leave). Eragon not wanting to abandon his unbord/born child and Saphira not wanting to loose her mate will follow Arya across the sea.

2) Eragorn dies and in some form of tradition he is shipped off to sea in a coffin. Remember no one was happy about the parting, and there was considerable wailing!

okay, i kinda like the second one, but i hate the first one for about 2 reasons:




1: Eragon and Arya? give me a break. i dont even care if there two dragons mate, its just sooooooo wrong. shes so old, ancient, wise, and completely foreign in nature to eragon.
2. the third dragon egg will probly be destroyed anyway.....

I do not like the idea of Eragon and Arya either, I would prefer it if he hooked up with that young elf, or the leader of the vardan (so tired I can not remember her name). But CP will probably write to the fans desire, and most people want to see him[Eragon] with Arya. Then again, I am hoping Eragon does not end up with anyone but loving followers.
I saw a comment earlier about how Eragon said he would leave to find a mate for saphira, that is a very plausable reason because I have a feeling thorn will be killed...and if the third and final egg is destroyed that makes it very possible for that ending to be true. As for why he never returned? It could be that he a) never found any more dragons, b) He fell in love with someone and could not leave an island c)Sapihra found a place where she could mate and raise her hatchlings in safety or finally D) Eragon and saphira find a new mate and start there own order of dragon riders, only to have them all perish or battle in another war on the orginal continent of man against the original razac.

b) He fell in love with someone and could not leave an island



i think that was originally my idea.



D) Eragon and saphira find a new mate and start there own order of dragon riders, only to have them all perish or battle in another war on the orginal continent of man against the original razac.



haha, i like that one.....

what if something so painful happens to eragon that he has to leave alagaesia

what if eragon leaves to find saphira a mate in one of the other lands. he promised saphira that he would help her search for a mate.

my idea already.....which means:

good idea! i guess great minds think alike! and that great mind would be yours cuz i dont have a great mind!!!!!

Your mind cant be that messed up (can it). I've been saying that for quite a while. Its the only theory that makes sense to me for why eragon will leave.

a contrare, it can......especially with school being like.....right now.....ugh.....



but yeah, it is the only possible explanation. ive been like saying that since eldest came out.....

I was about a year late getting on here after eldest came out.

well, you only joined like 11 days after me.....

rough but true. The only reason i'm not on here too often is because the stupid computer keeps kicking me offlline. Well i mean that i finished the book about a year before i joined.

yeah, i hate my computer too......it just ****** so bad.....i cant wait til i get a new one.....

Haha I just got myself a brandnew fancy laptop Anyways it will not be for Saphira to find a new mate "elitely". By which I meen there could be toher possible reasons. Perhaps Eragon goes in earch of the grey people who created the laws of magic to try and destroy magic once and foreall so that people would no longer have to live in fear of allmighty magic users? That does fit the plot, especially if Galby used a powerful enchantment to gain all his power. Perhaps Eragon is defeated and forced to leave in search of safe refuge however e is to cowardly to return. Or maybe Galby is defeated and flees Agelisia with Eragon hot on his tail. The two eternally chase one another across the multiple contenents until Eragon/Galby is finally defeated only to realize that after the chase they can not find their way home. As such they are forced to find a new home elsewhere. Perhaps Eragon uses a spell/enchantment to defeat Galby, but the paying cost is that he must leave agalesia. Or maybe Arya and the elves wish to leave to their homeland away from the warmongering humans so that they may live in peace, and Eragon being transformed into an elf is permitted to leave with them. Or maybe (see how many ideas ihave come up with in maybe 3 minutes of typing?) Eragon decides that the times of the dragonriders are finished and that it is his duty to take the dragons to live on another land, away from the inocents whom could be injured by another rouge rider. FINALLY, perhaps Eragon does indeed need to find Saphira a mate, but the search takes them so far from home that they can never return as their children could not find the way and that so much time has past, the way is lost to them...Okay i lied I had one more idea. The prophecy said spefically that "Eragon will never return" Perhaps under his true name he could? lol i will have to double check what it said in the book for that one...

wow, that took a lot of thought!!!! i like those theories, though!! augh, my brain would've burned out halfway through just thinking of those, neverhteless typing them!!!!

Yea once i start typing i sort of don't stop...thats why I was always able to finish my essay's for Uni. a day or two before the due date without typing out a single word before that. I am glad that there are multiple possible endings that can be theorized and seen in the books though. That meens that when the book comes out i will not fully know what to expect.

Yea once i start typing i sort of don't stop...thats why I was always able to finish my essay's for Uni. a day or two before the due date without typing out a single word before that. I am glad that there are multiple possible endings that can be theorized and seen in the books though. That meens that when the book comes out i will not fully know what to expect.

yeah......



there is one thing i can for the most part predict: murtagh is probably going to die.....



and what true justice that would be......

yeah, sj, ur right, murtagh probably will die, and eragon probably will leave to find saphira a mate.....its just sooooo predictable based on what cp wrote in eldest and eragon

or, like ive just come to a conclusion to in "saphira....dies?" topic, saphira will die and eragon will leave alagaesia in sorrow....never to return.

thats so sad, but could be completely true.......

yeah, it would be like total tragedy.....but its just a thought, probly wont have any chance at happening.....

i disagree mostly, if you all remember from when you read Eragon, right after Saphira hatched he had a dream about him and a women leaving with two dragons in the sky. the woman is obviously Arya, because if you remember Angela's reading, she said that he would be loved BY a women of royal birth, not he would love.
i doubt the other dragon is Murtagh's or Galbatorix's, and Glaedr is dead.

yeah, i'd have to agree with you now that i've read brisingr. what's probably going to happen is that eragon and arya have to go somewhere for something. The dragons flying in the sky are probably saphira and thorn, because saphira might actually get an interest in thorn (ew) but murtagh can't go with them (hence the man crying on the beach) for some reason. For some other reason, eragon can't come back from wherever they're going

they couldn't find wild dragons unless they had left already

Maybe the other dragon is Shruikin (sp), maybe he gets released from Galbatorix and lives happily ever after wherever they are

it could be shruikan.....i doubt it though....shruikan's probably going to die

shruikan probably doesn't even know he's controlled....it's black magic.

yeah, it's still probably going to be a couple of years

i don't it will be that long. CP had to split the 3rd book into 2 parts so he was probably is already half way through the 4th one before the 3rd one even came out

no, the reason he split the third one is because he knew it was going to be too long before he could finish it. so he split it where the 3rd book ended; he hadn't even started the 4th, he said so himself. and then he went on the world tour, so he just now got the chance to start writing again. it's going to be a while.

oh, i guess i missed that

it's okay. we all miss a lot

no, he has to leave in the inheritance cycle, because it all started in this.

and it ended in the inheritance cycle. everything that angela predicted is going to happen in the inheritance cycle. not another series. this one.

I think he leaves to go and look for the dragons that could exist in other lands with saphira as they (and the other dragon and rider) are the only ones who can really reach them

thank-you for backing up my point

He probably goes to find saphira a mate. Thats what i have thought for a long time.

yeah, probably from the other dragons too...

also, i think that thorn is only evil because he was enslaved into serving galby. I think that he is nice and wants to help defeat galby at heart but he cant do anything about it.

Please don't yell at me for saying that.

not sure how that pertains, but okay....


i really think thorn is evil. he was born in evil, has been raised in evil, and so will be evil

i don't know about that. Thorn's thinking would be like Murtagh and Murtagh hate Galb, but has to serve him because Galb knows his and Thorn's real names, so i don't think Thorn is evil

either way, its all thorn's known, and he won't want to leave it as easily as murtagh will. if murtagh even wants to

whel to back you up sj if saphira dies then they free murtagh then Arya gets an egg then that could be the dragons Arya could be the woman then it says that an elf lets out an acking scream so it could be because saphira dies and he is leaving forever

i hope that never happens that is saphira dieing that would stink so bad and i would burn all of my inheritence books and stop reading the book i was on

i like that theory. and if saphira died, it would be at the end, so you wouldn't miss much when you burnt your book

it just says that a man screamed or cryied on shore, not an elf, and i think the man is Roran, because him and Eragon are close and if he found that Eragon and Arya were leaving for good of course he would be cry in anguish.

no, he'd probably be happy for them. sad, but happy, seriously not grounds for crying in anguish

that's probably partailly true too, unless Katrina died and he is hurt because Eragon & Arya are leaving him, Katrina's dead and he has to take care of a baby. I'd cry in those shoes

again Eragon would have recognized Roran

but he might cry since he knows they arent coming back but not like the book described it

i don't think so. during the last two books it talked alot how the both Eragon and Roran's appearnces had changed throughout their travels and actions

your right

but still i think that roran wont be the one to cry

yeah, the situation doesn't quite fit. i don't think cp would be cruel enough to kill off enough characters to make roran cry anyway

i don't think so either, and i don't it to either, but i was just providing an explanation

ya, i dont think cp is that cruel, even though he killed Brom.

i read someplace where he said it was hard for him to write that, but he also said that he needed to do it. and i can see where Brom would have caused problems with the story line if he was still alive.

exactly. same with the other person who died (i can't say who for those who still might not have read the books)

yeah, i almost cried at that part, i'm not kidding, so imagine how CP felt. but it was nessicary, so who's to say that anyone besides Eragon and Saphira won't die. that puts a damper on the story till the read it though

well i doubt eragon will die. but saphira might

i hope not, she is the only reason i started reading the series and if she dies, after i finish the book, i'll throw away all my copies and never read a book by CP again. Maybe

well if cp ever writes again...but yeah, i semi-agree with you, though i'd love the sad ending

i think he should end the book with someone dying and eragon or whoever is leaving with whom. and then he should write a whole new book about the adventures in the land kinda like the epilogue. thatd b cool

yeah, someone else will definitely die in book 4 its just who

Yeah, i wonder if it will be Arya's mother(I couldn't spell her name), because she's already lost her father so if her mother died, then that would give her a reason to want to leave Alagaesia

oh you mean islanzadi? yeah, that could be a possibility

yeah,

please don't spam.




i still think it's going to be saphira, and that dream that eragon had is just gonna be a dream

i think islandi might die. sounds like a good theory to me.

yeah, but i still think it might be somebody more important

she's pretty important. She's the Queen of the Elves and Arya's mother, that fact that she is that alone makes her an important figure in the book

yeah, but we don't see much of her in the book. her name's mentioned, but not really her except in eldest

well i think she is going to play an important part in book 4 especially with Roran, Katrina, and Sloan.

maybe....but maybe she'll die after that important part

Yeah, she might dies. Then something involing Arya becomeing the next queen, like she sorta wants to, but maybe she also wants to go with eragon...

arya stated in eldest that she doesn't want to be queen

Yes but she willl if she has too

but she doesn't have to, there are plenty of other capable elves to rule

If she feels that it is neccessary for her to be the leader than she will be the leader

but she won't feel that way cuz some other elf will step up

Not if that elf is a bad choice

oh, it won't be...the elves are pretty good

lol but there are still elves who are selfich

but few and far between