MY PERSONAL THEORY IS THAT IT IS ERAGON, ARYA, AND THE REMAINDER OF THE ELVES (THE REST GET WIPED OUT IN BATTLE) AND RORAN IS ON THE BEACH

that is highly possible, but i like the idea that they are leaving Galby powerless on an island after they have killed Shruikan and they rename Alagaesia. lol. that'd be cool, but i doubt it.

me too

yeah i really like the theory about galby being left powerless on the beach( being that i created it).
but don't count that theory out, as far as we know cp could throw us a curveball and have ary die. that would be cool, right I'MNOTCRAZY.

lol. do i have to kill you AND Lava-Golem???? lol.

as long as you kill arya too

lol, your off topic and there are already 3 topics about this, I think one might be Nasuadua

No it's Arya and that dude we all thought died in the beginning on the ship, and Eragon screaming on the beach.

i think its Eragon and Arya leaving Alagaesia forever and on the beach Roran or Mutagh is screaming

if there were elves on there it would seem too much like LOTR

that's why i like my endong. they leave Galby on an island and they rename Alagaesia! it's unexpected, nothing like LOTR, and it WORKS. lol. it's the best thing that has nothing to do with LOTR that anyone has come up with here. now THAT'S true.

i agree with the theory someone posted that galby is on the beach helpless, with arya & roran aboard

why would eragon leave roran on the beach? he's like a brother to him , and their relationship will surely only get stronger in the third book.

no, galby on the beach, arya & roran on deck

I also think this, but I think it is only Eragon and Arya that get on the boat. Not all the other elves. But I think it is Roran on the beach though.

no, a large group of people including two taller than the rest, a man and a woman, board the boat. check pg 81 Eragon

NO when you get hit with a half dozen arrows in the chest, YOU DIE

O rly? How do you know he wasn't wearing an armor of some kind?

ok armor might stop arrows from far away but bows are very powerful maybe if armor was magic or had a spell on it, but read this:

"The Urgalls deadly arrows quickly broght down the two elves. They fell from their noble horses, blood pooling in the dirt." Pg. 3 Eragon "Shade of Fear"

lets see, combine multiple arrows to the chest, falling of your horse, blood coming out of you, no mention of survivors in any of the books, and the fact that i think that they said that either elves or varden found bodies of urgals and i think elves. they're dead!!!

We know that those two are dead because Arya would of gone after them if they were.

yes she loved faolin and if she knew he was alive she would have tried to find him if he wasn't like with galby in ur'rubaen, in which case she would have died

Which probably was where she was taken to be mind ingested upon thing.

HUH???? mind ingested??? anyways, the large # of people are elves because many have silver hair and carried tall lances. that pretty much describes elves

from what i've been reading, i highly doubt it's faolin on a boat with arya, or glenwing for that matter. It said there are 2 dragons in the sky, and only 1 egg left. Why would saphira leave eragon? or maybe it's oromis and arya, elva, ect.

nononono oromis dies. he is worried about the time he has to train eragon

That's right, Oromis doesn't have that much time left. I think it is Eragon and Arya on the boat and Roran on the beach yelling after them.

thank you someone who agrees with what i say, at least more than 1 thing at a time

What do you mean by that?

i like it when people agree with me, and they dont always, or only with part of what i say

and you basicaly agreed with my main theory: eragon and arya, oromis diening, roran on shore, etc

Oh, no prob. But I think Roran is rider and not Arya.

but then the race of dragons dies and only two or three will be left, and saphira the only female and she goes w/ eragon to alalea or wherever.

i still think that its Eragon and Arya leaving Algaesia forever and someone screaming for them not to go, i think that the leaving Galby on an Island theory is good they could leave him on Sharktooth the barren waste land os an island. that would eb good, but i have a gut feeling that it is Eragon and Arya leaving Alagaesia forever and Saphira and Greenie flying in the background

but couldnt galby use magic to get himself to the mainland?

he could i suppose another reason why he just dies

I think Eragon Arya get on the ship to go to Alagae[spelling?] And Murtagh is the one on the beach. Greenie and Saphira are the Dragons in the sky!


I know I'm right, you wait....

i reckon it is eragon arya and the rest of the elves

Tis Eragon And Ayra, also 2 taller then others...the rest being Dwarfs!