What do you think would happen to Thorn? My opinion is that he will kill Galbatorix within the last second. That'd be pretty cool. Please reply to this quetion. Thanks dudes.

We'll he can't kill galby at the moment, because he is still under his control. That would be cool though, and a great twist! All I hope is we learn more about him and Murtagh.

Yeah! Maybe Thorn will be able to mate with Saphira to. That'd be pretty cool.

Heh, yeah. There's a whole topic about who Saphira could mate with somewhere! Thorn or new (likely green) dragon are the best candiates.

I just hope neither thorn dies cause then it will be like galby allover again ccept with murtagh

Me to. Thorn seems like a good dragon. It just sucks that he was forced to be evil.

Saphria was supposed to mate with the new green dragon... I think that Eragon will life the spell that binds Murtah and Thron like he will Elva and then together they will rescue the last dragon egg and murtagh helps eragon defeat Gilbatrox and the Razac

Thats an intresting theory too.

Ya but it would take geting murtagh like cornered in ellesmera and all the elves, oromis, gleadr, eragon, and saphira together to lift it. Hey thats a theory. Magical, curse-lifting ambush! and anyway, Gallobitorix(sp) knows Murtagh's true name.. But.. maybe that has something to do with saying your name on the whatever rock in the vault of souls? maybe there is some way for the souls there to change Murtagh.. Well technically, change who he is. But.. Dragons have powerful magic when they need to. Maybe Saphira, Thorn, and Gleadr can do something? I mean, they fixed eragon and he had a constantly worsening epilipsy (probably because the sword hit his spine.) If they can fix that, surely they could do something... I dunno i just wish CP would hurry up.. but not so fast its a bad book

You cant rush perfection.

true... but i can still wish.

THe longer it takes the better it will be

You know what? Hadarac is right. It always seems better if it takes longer and the last book is supposed to be better then the first and second one. I hope so.

I hope it is the longest too. Eragon was average, Eldest was a bit longer, so lets hope the 3rd book it even longer than eldest!

Plus you're right, the longer it takes to write, the better it should be.

Do you mean like 700 pages or somethin?

Yeah, I like lots and lots of pages!!!

That must mean that youre a big reader then. Like me.

lol! Only good books with a fast pace, like eragon and eldest. I like a lot of description, but not if it takes up 200 pages!

I dont know what you mean by fast pace.

Well, kind of like not staying on one subject for ages and ages. Like keep moving onto new places, or events instead of describing one section of something in huge detail. Basically, not boring!

Oh. Yes bad books are boring. I didn't like reading until I found Eragon and Eldest.

I know what you mean! Anyway, what do you think will happen to Thorn?

I came up with a new theory. I think that he may help turn Murtagh to good again. What do ya think?

Maybe, but galby knows thorn's true name as well, so they are both evil. I just want to know his personality!

I think that when I'll be reading last book you all will already know everything...but in my opinion will Thorn die because Paoliny like big battles and its pretty hard to kill dragon (in my opinion). The best will be bad end Eragon dead and Saphira with offspring from Galbatorix dragoon

That would be a terrible ending! I'd be so angry!

For me it'd be just surprising end
If I'll write a book it will have a bad ending

That would suck if Eragon died. I would be very angry if Galbatorix won.

Hey what do you have against...sounds interesting!

Almost everythin!! Gallby will not prevail!!

Aren't you all bored by still same happyending?
It's all time same...sympathic guy come to the lands of big bad king, guy have few problems and in the end he win...it's becoming boring Death of main heroes should do

Do you have a murderous mind?

NO!!!!!!!!!
My mind is allright

Okay. Just wanted to make sure. Sorry if it was offending.

Ihope 1000 something pages then it wont take me only liek 4 days to read

That's allright

Cool. What do you think will happen to Thorn Incomer?

In my opinion Thorn is one of the less important characters because Safire doesn't seems to like him (egg eater or something like this ) And there is still one more egg so Thorn has free future...I think he'll go on light side(star wars forever) and together with Murtagh Eragon and Saphira he will rule

Ah.

But there's still the matter of breaking them from the oath.

*shrug* I have no idea.

Ok I'm saying from begginning death will be the easier way

Easier way eh?

Here is what really happens according to my dad


Galby is Eragons father (yeah right we have a bet on that one i am so gonna win)

Murtagh and thorn are lifted from galby's little spell do thingy

and of course knowing my dad he doesnt have a clue what color the dragon is going to be

me i hope it is green

Luke I'm your father! NOOOOOOOOOOOOO!
Do you know where was it?

I take it that you like starwars to?

In my opinion is Episode I and II something absolutly horrible and it has destroyed good name of star wars but I don't have anything against them

Oh. But im not much of a fan of starwars though. Its at least not my fave thing.

Thorn is not under Galbys control but Murtagh is
Thorn is his own person u see

really? i dont get it?

Galby controls Murtagh be makin promises in AL but thorn doesn't Murtagh don't control Thorn so horn can do wat he wants

Galby controls both Murtagh and Thorn, because he knows both of their true names.

i thought he knew eragons and Murtaghs

If he knew eragon's true name, then eragon would already be working for him, right? When Murtagh says "He knows our true names" he meant his and thorn's, not his and eragon's.

Ys the 2nd book called eldest

Because Murtagh is the eldest son of Morzan.

oh anyway do dragon have true names

Everything has a true name. That's how you can gain control over that object.

so if you knew the true name of an ant u could control it

Obviously, yes. Can we get back on topic please.

ok

he sent his men on a quest to findd them

NOOOOOOOOOOOO! ABOBINATION, NOOO NOT WITH THORN!!!

i wouldn't be bothered by saphira being with thorn as long as he is truely good at heart.
we will see about that in the next book.
by the way. good explaining firetunge. you pointed out the right thigs about the names.

What happen when you mix green and blue color?

blue and green gives you blue-green. red and blue would give you purple.
but i don't think the parents color will compleatly determind the color of the hatchlings.

Still I'm curious what will it do...I don't have any colors since I don't have painting as a school subject

well, blue-green in itself is a color. its really pretty. its one of my favs.

I LOVE ALL SHADES OF BLUE!!!!! as of what will become of the RED Dragon, (Remember him, the topic ) I really do not know or have an inkling of an idea of what shall become of him. Since I do not like the side he belongs to, I dismissed him from my mind.

Oh yeah you're right I was talking about a new dragon (still egg ) uhm sorry...
Ok another question-what happen when you mix blue and red color?!?

You get a purple dragon!!!

Here we go...I can't wait till i'll see wonderfull purple sword of some mighty dragon rider (I'm pretty sure I said somewhere else it will happen )

But for there to be a purple sword, then there should be a purple dragon. Maybe that would encourage my teenager to read the series, as it is her favorite color. LOL!

annie. i know thorn is on the wrong side. but he is being controled by galby. that may not be in his real nature.
at least i hope is is good at heart. i don't like the thought of evil dragons. i like em too much.

no clue

I know you are probably right; and deep inside I cannot bear the thought that he, as a dragon, is evil. To be fair, maybe not even Gabatorix's black dragon could be left out of this catoegory as he also is controlled by him. I have not been able to speculate as to what end will CP give to them, and that scares me!

true true.
but as i said before. i have faith in cp. you have to have faith in the writter. i'm sure a good end will come to all.
i do wonder about galby's blac dragon as well. i'm sort of sad for the poor guy.
being forced to hatch for an evil guy you didn't pick. then help him destroy your own kind, and live out life under his control. poor thing doesn't even know any diffrent.
but i'm sure cp will get them all freed

Oh happy will be so cool and surprising (imagine a lot of sparks and fireworks ale thousands of happy dancing people...)

I think that murtaugh and thorn will somehow break free from galby's spell. So i think that thorn just becomes a rider's dragon. Now how they will break free from spell will be different story

I think for now they have both taken the wrong path in their lives, that is quite obvious. I am hoping that Thorn survives just like Murtagh and that they, both will return to the good side. I think Thorn will help Murtagh and the other riders and fight against Gably. Somehow I think there is more to Thorn than meets the eye and whatever happens to Thorn has a purpose...I just hope this is what happnes.

i think they will brake free from galbys curse or ormis (sp) might help brake the curse

I think Thorn save Saphira just before she die becuse he loves her

no. that would go in the wishful thinking topic in the Book 3 subforum!

i rekon somethin more will happen something..unexpected im not sure wat yet tho but i think it will be totally different from anything else...............

i reckon the elves might lift the spell from Murtagh and Thorn and galby somehow 4gets Murtaghs and thorns names and then they can help the varden. but its just a pretty stupid theory and i dont think it'll come true but there's a posibility!

ya neva know till u read it lol
they might be able to put a memory thing on galby and shruikin making them both forget about them but it would be hard to do.
Maybe Murtagh is about to kill eragon and galby comes and murtagh kills galby and joins eragon.

I don't think Thorn is going to die. What happens to Thorn depends on what happens to Murtagh. And I totally have no idea what's going to happen to him.

murtagh has a dragon?

So far its basically Thorn saves lives, and/or breaks free of Galbs control

I think he dies.

If you've read Eldest, you'll know the answer to that =3

caterpillar we ruined the book for somebody

He and Saphira could get together

perhaps, and quite likely

Yeah, and he could turn good (i do not know how) and help kill galby

do u think he will turn good though?

if eragon kills thorn murtagh will go crazy

If Eragon kills thorn that will only make me sad.

Well i dont know about killing galbatorix. But i think that saphria will mate with the green dragon.[/code]

maybe, depends on the dragons personality.