you really think someone like eragon can be with someone like arya happily for infinity?

well i do
if Eragon grows up a bit

hm... very odd person

but it could also grow eragon up in a bad way. it could harden his heart against people, especially if he leaves alagaesia, never to return

I really want some of Eragons close friends to die.... I know it sounds evil but it would make the story better, and
I WANT ARYA TO DIE!!!!
not because I'm evil but it would be very really good for Eragon to get a life and make things more dramatic....

i agree wholeheartedly on both of those points. like murtagh should die to move the story along, and arya should die so eragon can move on with his pathetic life and leave alagaesia

orik is good friend of his too
i think he will die.

yeah, probably by murtagh's hand...driving eragon farther away from alagaesia.

yea... Murtagh should let Eragon to kill him and his dragon.
probably

yes, and then eragon will leave alagaesia

but where will he go?

idk, some other land. preferably with dragons. he has to, it's part of the prophecy

he becomes a king in brisingr? cool
we yea so he probably won't die ... and so probaby arya will

but no - she can't die! so i think murtagh and roran will.

No-one believes me, but Murtagh, Thorn, and Ayrea will die in book 4.

you obviously haven't read any of my posts. i believe you

Probably nasuada or orik. But we know galbatorix will die.

well except in the case of a mass cleansing of populations...

well this whole thing is chaos. so that's not really a good reason for orik not to die. there just needs to be tragedy in all areas of eragon's life so he will felt led to leave alagaesia never to return

Ayrea will probably die trying to save someone from death.

she will prolly die saving eragon

It is very likely, but she WILL die as far as I am concerned.

I'm sorry, but Ayrea's death is the only one that wouldn't effect the world completely. Orik would disrupt the gov of the dwarves, the Elves already have a queen, and more than likely back-up pland. Orrin wouldnt effect it too much. Eragon & Saphira, do I really have to explain that one.

I do not want Arya to die but she could....i think Islanzadi will die

ha, i figured it out! (this was posted by me under eragon's true name topic)


eragon's true name should be figured out by galby, then eragon will change his true name and kill galby. then galby will kill him with magic at the last second. saphira will go crazy and kill thorn, murtagh will kill saphira, murtagh will kill himself, islanzadi will slip on a banana and fall, arya will then kill herself, and orik will just bury himself in a hole. there, all problems solved.

lolz

Orik:He wont die because the dwarves have already lost a king

Islandi:She probably will not die but will witness the death of Ayrea

Orrin:If he died then it wouldn't matter because Surda would become part of the "empire" under the leadership of somepne

Eragon/Saphira:They wont die

Murtagh/Thorn:They wil die in final battle either asttacking Eragon or Galby

i still like mine better....lol

lolz, I would too lolz.

its just total mass destruction. me likey. lol. me likey magical atomic bomb too. lol

god no

arya can't die ... she has to be elves queen!
probably islandzi will die and arya will take over the elves kingdom. xD

RUBEN-ELDA you are contradicting yourself!!! You said in another topic that she would go with Eragon to where ever they go, she cant do both, lol shes gona die, mark my words!

Then who is the elf he is leaving on the boat with ? He's not just going to fall for someone else in the span of one book, CP has spent too much time on their interaction in the first 3 books for that to happen.

Eragon and Arya= Aragorn and Arwen. They will overcome their culture difference and their age diffence and get together eventually.

SIGH!!!!!!!
LOTRdoes not =the Eragon cycle.
He does not have to completely copy Tolkeen(sp)
He does not have to do anything like that, and no they are not that same person!
You have good ideas, but you do not and will not know for a FACT that is how it will happen.

arya stated in eldest that she has no interest of being the queen

not necessarily. i'm sure there are other elves capable of being a queen/king

Naa, he isn't an elf no matter how much he looks like them, he will probably never be accepted as a King to them.

well, cp wouldn't of had her say that she didn't want to be queen if she was going to be queen

Arya and Eragon will be together no mattter what they end up being. Either king and queen or just travellers. And i believe Arya will not be Queen unless she sees it as the best thing for her people

Ayra will die, Murtagh & Thorn will die, Galby & Shurikan will die, & Eragon and Saphira will lose something dear to them.

But honestly who dies really depends on ho the next rider is....because you need to have two dragons left and one has to be saphira.

Well, we really don't know if there will be a rider...

If the dragon hatches there will have to be a rider

There might not be a rider, unless & I cant remember was it forced to be bonded??, anyway it probably wont hatch untill end of IV.

Wow you just don't stop. CP has confirmed that the cover of book 4 will be of the green dragon because it plays an important part. He is writing the book, not you. This "it won't hatch till the end" theory has absolutely no vaildation behind it.

Lol, you hear that.....(silence) woa, its everyone who cares.

Uh buddy plenty of people on here have agreed with me. Don't get mad at me because I actually use facts and logic.

Why do you completely ignore facts and logic and CP's word ?

Because I like what I like & don't like what I don't like, and there are others who will back me up on this.

It has nothing to do with liking or disliking things, it has to do with ignoring facts and logic. It's like saying Alfred is actually Batman while Bruce Wayne is actually Superman.

if the dragon hached in the book it would help him much in fight =ing Galby the new rider would need training. And you can't say they can rush the training like Eragon because he still wouldn't be helpful

I agree with you voenth

Just because the dragon hatches(which CP has confirmed) doesn't mean it will have to fight. Also if Arya is the new rider she will not need much training as she is already great in fighting both with a sword and with magic.

That makes two of us lol
Exactly, how can the dragon possibely be trained when the only riders there are are Murtagh/Thorn, Galby/Shurikan, and Eragon/Saphira who are all busy fighting it would be a liability. And an extremely easy target for Murtagh/Thorn, and or Galby/Shurikan.

okay what makes you think Arya is the new rider? and if the Dragon doesn't fight then what use is it? If you think the second Saphira and Greenie are going to mate the second it hatches then eww. And if Saphira got pregnant then she couldn't fight.

and you don't need to quote everybody

1- Cp said the new rider is someone who is in all the books.
2- CP said he dropped some obvious hints as to who will rider the green dragon.... Arya= green magic, green eyes.

Aside from that I can't think of any hints he has dropped for any other character.

The green dragon will just interact with several of the characters but will not actually fight any of the dragons.

I just figured it out!
Its Roran. Hes in all 3 books. He dosn't have extremely bonding tyes with Eragon ans Saphira. And to keep from that bond between Saphira and Greenie from flowing over to Eraogn and Roran that is why Eragon leaves to find Saphira a mate!!!!!!!

no Roran ouldn't want to be a rider he has to go home and raise a family with Katrina
Maybe Nasuada shes in a three books, she has a crush on Eragon, and she is strong.

but were's off topic
Arya, Murtagh, Thorn, and someone else is going to die

Yea, they will die Galby will too lol!

That would be really cruel for Roran, he doesn't want to become immortal and outlive his wife and kid.

Plus there are no major hints for him and CP has put a lot of emphasis on how great a fighter Roran is even without and magic powers.

Also what do you mean he doesn't have bonding ties with Eragon. He and Eragon have a very close bond, unless you meant magical bond.

yes MWHAHAHA!!!
DEYJA! DEYJA! DEYJA!

Since when does Nasuada have any sort of crush on Eragon ? We see her POV several times and not once does she feel anything other than friendship for Eragon.

Well, I guesss you are right though it does fit him well, IN all 3 books, close to Eragon, related to riders, and he is more of a farmer (earth) which is green, I like the idea.

you do realize that dream is probably screwed, right? you can't base fact on that

but when has eragons dreams been wrong before???(seriously i cant remember im about to read the books again)

Who says that anyone has to die? Eragon proably leaves with Arya (Who might become the green dragon rider) for some reason. Roran gets his wish and goes back to Carvanhall with his wife, and Naus becomes the next queen after Galby. And Murt.... Um, there's a theroy that during the "big battle" He changes his true name and kills Galby.

Well she is boring because Eragon has very little time with her.

Alright easy there crazydragon girl, i never said she wasn't a good character, but you have to keep in mind we have not had much time to see her real character. She is a secondary character

if islanzadi dies wouldn't that clear the way for arya to become the next queen.

right but if she WERE to become queen then how could that affect the fate of alagaesia.

How can you even like bladesinger...she was in like 3 pages not even and we know nothing about her

yeah we don't know too much about her.

because in eragon, eldest, and brisingr, someone/somepeople have died. so some are probably gonna die in book 4 (AKA DEYJA!!!)

yeah when the book is called DEYJA!!! somepeople have to die

yeah, and its kinda almost guaranteed that galby's gonna die, so that mean that someone has to die