oh she knows.. but she might wait a little while b4 telling him.. idk why

ya, she might tell him at the beginning of empire, it makes sense

ya, saphira will see how eragon is soo upset about morza ( sp ) being his pappy that she will tell him brom was his real dad

she will probably tell him while they're in the air so he couldn't do anything to her (just a thought)

But there is still a good possibility that she doesn't know.

i think she knows, she just doesn't want to break it out upon him too hard

that makes more sense than the "saphira knowing who eragon's father is" theory

man annibee you are always their with the quotes and theorys that always make sense.. it must be cuz your a mother and they seem to always know everything...

That makes the most sence out of all the how Eragon finds out theories Ive heard! Noce gob!!!!

theirs thoes little details that we all miss but when you read the book 25 + times you see and remember them all..

man, anniebee, you have awesome memory!

lol ya when i reread the books.. i always find atleast 1 thing that i missed when i read it the time b4

i guess i have a lot of reading a head of me! i'm just starting to read eragon a second time.

lol ya you do.. it takes me like maybe a day or to to read them

wow! i probably will read eragon fast, it's been over 104*F for the past couple of days

hmmm do you live in arizona or california?

california, and it's been SOOO hot in the bay area!!!

i live in michigan but its still been pretty hot here

it's 95* right now, and it feels SOOO GOOD!!! i've never thought that i'd be so happy in 90* weather!

wait annibee where do you live?? ( i htink i asked you this once before )

yeah, you are confusing me.
anyway, let's get back on topic

ya getting off topic is soo easy.. me and elvenwarrior get off topic so much when hes on.. ( which he isnt ) but ya back on topic.. i htink that saphira got every one of brom's memories so that she could help eragon w/ things that he would need answers too.. like who is his pappy

where in california?
Lord Imfamous, i don't think saphira knows all of brom's memories.

all we know for sure is that brom let saphira into his memories to see other dragons

Which is why I don't believe that she knows about Brom being Eragon's father. Her emotions would clue Eragon in to something if he did!

havent you guys read eldest yet thats were you find out who eragons dad is

That is what CP wants you to think. I have gathered evidence proving that Brom is Eragon's father.

ya brom is eragons pappy.. not morzan

why did you say pappy

Maybe he was getting tired of using the word father???

i said pappy cuz pappy sounds kool.. dad is to normal

still, thats what my grandpa says

I don't think anyone wants to be like your grandpa...

and that would mean what

I don't know.....

you always enjoy ruining things dont you

yea, everybody is getting WAY off topic

no, she just knows her facts and she tells us them which are usually right

and for a good reason

elvenwarrior, what is that supposed to mean?

we were off topic for a good reason

ok, but can we PLEASE get back on topic? i'm tired of people arguing about the next rider on every single topic!!!

I came up with A TON of evidence that Brom is Eragon's father.

is that why you were gone and then came back? fire away with the evidence!

LOL!!! I am your worst nightmare!!! Besides, it was I who opened the topic!!



Excuse me, but I've been frying my brains on this site and with the books longer than you! But you are RIGHT, you have contributed a lot to re-affirm that Brom is Eragons father!

so, do you like ruining things, anniebee?

no, shes just good at it

man, she's good at a lot of stuff, isn't she?

yes, and shes reallly smart cuz she nos like every little detail about eragon and eldest

well, she's read them at least 25 times

exactly my point.. she read them alot so she nos every little detail

so, what do you think saphira knows that she hasn't told eragon?

alot of things.. like how brom is his dad.... hm and other secrets that might be important.. like where the vault of souls is maybe

No, I don't. I just don't like useless discussions which do not add anything to the topics. And let's face it, some ideas are so ridiculous, that it seems that poster is only answering to gain post count. Those I really dislike.


Lord Imfamous, I am baffled! I thought we were friends! But you know what, you're right!
My daughter just had to come and see why I was laughing so hard! She believes I am crazy!

lol.... i seem to have that effect on some people..

i'm laughing at that part right now !!! anyway, i hate useless discussion, too, anniebee!

What just happened??? Did I miss something???

LOL! That's what happens when you're trying to be at two sites at the same time! I know, by experience!!!

Elvenwarrior thinks I'm a party "pooper"(sp), and Lord Imfamous and dragon_lover are calling me a "know-it-all" and my daughter is telling me "I'm crazy" and she wants to call 911 so they can place me in a straight jacket AND to top it all, WE ARE ALL OUT OF TOPIC, AGAIN!

btw, I'm on this site and Booksnmore and it's fine! I went to eat some dinner!

i enjoy your long answers, anniebee.

ok, let's get back on topic

AnnieBee why do you type everything in cyan

i never realized that, i like it

i think it matches your avatar, and you do pay attention to detail

Thanks! Well you see, blue is my favorite color, and this blue makes reading a pain, otherwise I would have had the light blue on my avatar, but we don't have it on the site's color scheme, so I opted out for cyan.

i never thought i would tell anniebee this, but STAY ON TOPIC, lol that was fun

you weren't exactly staying on topic!!!

i know, which im trying to fix now

LOL! You are a bad influence. Guys, let's get back on topic. Why would Saphira turn her face away from Eragon, at the end of the battle of the Burning Plains if she knew she would be able to offer Eragon some comfort?

why am i a bad influence

i think that she knows that brom is eragon's father

but seriously, why am i a bad influence

Then give us a reason why she didn't tell him. He is mature enough by now.

maybe she asked oromis when she should tell eragon, and he said that he will?

Elvenwarrior: LOL! You are a bad influence.
Because now I am the one constantly getting off topic. You spoiled me!


I'MNOTCRAZY: That's just it, why she did not tell him then and there is beyond me. It would have been a perfect moment to tell something, even if not all, to give him some comfort!



I have to go cook now, I'll be back later!

are you gonna cook with beer? (i know, that was off topic)

Yes, as a matter of fact I am. It's chicken stewed in beer, white rice, Green salad and fried plantains.

The only reasonI can think why not then is that, as I've said before, CP may want the character of Oromis, give him answers to all he asks! Other than that, I am at a total lost!

That's the only feasible reason I can think of!

i think oromis will die right before saying something important

There is no evidence to back that!

That's true, but your theory is plausable.

Yeah, but he has to figure it out sometime.

NO!!! Eragon has to find out about his father!

i still think morzan is eragon daddy thats what me and my friend devon think

Other than Murtagh saying it, which isn't really proof, there are no reason for you to believe that it's true.