Why oh why can't you just for once actually read what I'm saying?
Is that so hard?

This is what I said:

From what CP has said, Arya is the only one who fits as the next rider(If his isn't lying)
I wasn't saying that CP has said that Arya was the only one who fits.
I said: From what CP has said (by that I mean using the information he gave us) we do see that Arya is the only one who fits.

What I actually said about what CP has said was this:

And CP has said that book four continues the adventures of Eragon, Saphira and Arya.

Which doesn't mean that Arya and Eragon are the ones leaving in his dream. It could mean something else entirely. And mk, why would CP even put in the height thing if it wasn't to be taken literally? Why would he even mention their height if it didn't matter.
By the way Librarian, I'm not trying to say that they won't be the ones leaving. They probably are. I'm just making a point of how sloppily CP is doing it.

To be honest, I can't say or prove anything about the dream. I have said how I look upon it. But the height is one thing.

There are much more pointinmg the other way.
It was Eragon who dreamt the dream. Eragon is domed to leave Alagesia. Nothing can change that. There is two dragons in the skie. From what CP has said Arya is the only one who can fit as the next rider (If his isn't lying)
Eragon loves Arya and dosn't want any one else. In the dream we see a man and a woman bording the ship. And CP has said that book four continues the adventures of Eragon, Saphira and Arya.

But you are right. CP has probably been sloppy with that part.

I think their height matters but all it says is that they're taller than the rest. Nothing more. Again, no one character let alone characters fit that particular description. Three books out and no one stands out in that way. However, it is Eragon's dream, it is most likely that he is directly involved in the dream and since he is the only one we know of that is actually fated to leave Alagaesia forever, it makes the most sense that he's the one arm and arm with the woman. Eragon has these kind of dreams per CP because he is a powerful magician and has always been a powerful magician and because he is in the middle of so much that is going on right now.

I know all of that. And as I said to the Librarian I'm not trying to disprove that they are leaving. I'd have to be insane to try that.
One thing I do have a problem with is when you said Eragon has always been a powerful magician. Didn't he nearly die when he fought those urgals?

I agree. Eragon hasn't always been a poweful magician. And yes, he nearly did die when he fought those urgals.

Eragons magical power and knowleged didn't came until after his transformation in the Agaetí Blödhren. Before that he wasn't powerfull at all. Not alone at least. He did had Saphira, but him self was not strong at all.

man you guys are taking this, I think, a little too personally... there are other things to consider than just the outside looks, and dreams. Anything can happen in dreams, and it could have been his dream that he was leaving, and I know he's doomed to leave, but it doesn't have to be with arya, and the dragons might not actually be going with them. it just said that they were circling above, but that could just be that they are saying good-bye or something...

Well we do try to use every bit of information to prove our views...but that's all part of a good debate isn't it?
Anyway, there is no way any of us will be able to nail down what the dream means. We can get a good idea, but it's rather pointless anyways.

there could be a possibility that maybe the dream has some kind of meaning in teh last book, but we won't know for sure until teh book actually comes out.

But until the last book comes we can choose between thinking logicaly or going on the gut feeling. I choose the first one.

And this isn't just about the dream. There are loads of more things who are saying that Eragon will leave and that it will be Arya. And I don't know what you think Kvista, but I strongly think that CP made that dream for a reason.

yeah, that's true, and perhaps he's going to refer to it a lot.

What other visions??? The only other "vision" I can remember is when he dreams about Arya.


CP has over 200 pages of thing he has taken away from the books.
I'm sure that he put the dream there because he didn't have any thing else. Or just for fun. It would be so stupid to put that dream there for a reason.....
Yes. That was sarcasm. And I'm sure that the fact that Angela condemed him to leave Alagesia a couple of pages later was just a coincidence. Particularly since the dream had nothing with dragons or leaving..... Yea... that was also sarcasm.

CP has his own plans for what he wants to put into his books.

But he did mess up book three with a particular plan involving a shade.
I'm just saying., he may have plans, but they may not necessarily be good ones.

Well, they don't have to worry about that shade anymore because Arya killed it.

Indeed. all three had a hand in killing varaug just as all three had a hand in killing durza.
gomensigh, you said earlier that eragon wasn't in any of his other visions right?

Hmmm. You are right on that. Which means the vision of the people getting on the boat doesn't have to be of him. Thanks for that.

What does that have to do with him not being powerful? Besides, it's not what I said, it's what Paolini said. Doesn't mean you guys can't disagree with him but that's what he said and that's where I got it from.



That has always been possible, it just isn't likely in my opinion. Eragon leaving Alagaesia forever as seen by a sailing ship that Angela reads when telling his future and then has a dream about a group of people leaving on a sailing ship with dragons involved and the most likely conclusion is that Eragon isn't leaving with those people? Look I really don't want to be an ass about it but that isn't logical.