Eh its true, they can stand up and speak their mind, but that doesn't mean they can be rude about it. I thought the movie needed a little more linkage to the book but I didn't go making web sites about it. They just doing it for attention and to see how mad they can get people.

How come this topic is in the local news and announcements forum?

I don't go to CP and inheritance trilogy bashing sites.

Well if you think about it, its news about what other sites are doing And the SF team must think its fine if they hvnt moved it.

True, but then again i could move this topic if i wished, but I won't. (I can moderate the first two forums.)

I just followed the url and i think it is gona be deleted.

Too bad for you that it is the internet, it will never get deleted, if the owner for ever pays the fees of having it, just like myself, I could keep saphiraforums.com for 20 years ...

At first I liked Eragon, but after I looked at it as a book, I myself thought it was cliched and poorly written, but that's my opinion. I'm not ashamed of the way I feel, but I don't understand why some make such a big deal about it. People read books everyday, and sometimes they don't like them. Can anyone honestly say that they've never read a book they disliked for some reason or another? Maybe, maybe not. Read reveiws on Amazon- people dislike some books all the time. The Anti-fans should have a place to state their opinions and have a place to share them with others.

yeah, people are entitled to there opinion but, they shouldnt be critisizing people who like and cp who wrote it like anti surtugal does. because seriosly, they are huge jerks.

didnt we fix that guest problem a while ago?

edit: oh nvm mind, louis made a new feture, i dont really like it though.

why would they make that website. do they hate it so much?

[quote]yeah, people are entitled to there opinion but, they shouldnt be critisizing people who like and cp who wrote it like anti surtugal does. because seriosly, they are huge jerks.
[/quote]

Some people just don't like Paolini's writing. It isn't, however, fair to say that all anti-fans dislike Paolini or the people who like his books. Most anti-fans simply dislike Inheritance. Yes, there are some who dislike and pick on Paolini, which isn't right at all, but likewise, and fairly, there are fans who dislike the anti-fans as much. If you actually look at many anti-fans, they aren't criticizing Paolini or fans, just his writing.

I'm an anti-fan. Do you think I'm acting like a jerk?

im not saying all anti fans are, just most of the guys on anti surtugal because they insult cp and all people who like inheritance. and like the other guest said, its ok to not like it, but to make a website just to make fun of some ones hard work is just sad.

anyways, if you dont like inheritance just dont come here. its as simple as that.

i agree with you 100%. but i just hate it when people are idiots about it. the same thing happens with runescape. people call me a gay retard for liking runscape and i despise it. most of them havnt even played it and have just heard about it from there friends.

Hmmmm...well if Anti-Shurtugal insults CP thats really their problem. But yeah, some people (Inheritance fans) insult the anti's, like firetongue said, and it makes them look bad.

Believe it or not, many anti-fans realize that both sides have been known to insult the other obsessively. In fact, if you have a few moments, the web mistress of the anti-Shur'tugal discusses this in an article warning Anti-fans [i]not[/i] toinsult fans or Paolini. [url] http://www.anti-shurtugal.com/wordpress/?p=36[/url]

i agree that it is perfectly fine to dislike a series, but just to have a place to rave about it and make fun of it is a bit extreme

big deal. she went in length posting the 4 basic rules of debating that any good debater knows. I'm not going to break them besides calling them bottom-feeding scum. jk, but I would like to undermine their integrity in obsessing over negative feelings. It's not healthy, and any shrink would say that.

It often keep's the anti's off the actual fansites though. So thats a plus.

SO YOU ARE CALLING IT A NOT-ACTUAL FANTASY??? AND STOP DEFENDING THEM!!! TRAITOR!!!

i agree if they were onhere it would first be annoying and them most likly bullying or watever other abuse there is what probably happen.

1. I never actually gave you permission to use my name outside of BNM, and 2. it's not fair that u know mine and I don't know yours...humph...

Sauron's a traitor. no questioning that Firetongue.


@ Dragonzroc: this is a FANsite. we'd kick them out for harassment anyways.

good point!!

no, annie, i havn't been to any, but if you hate a series so much that you create a site just to rant about it and make fun of it, then you either
a)need to grow up
b)need to get a life
c)take a vacation

pick 3

Hmmm...

But the anti's have a point that eldest is miles away from being perfect. In MY opinion anyway.

I don't support Anti-Shurtugal.Com (Come on people capital letters are a very important part of our society!), but I was a member a while back to find out about their views, and they have some solid points.

I don't care though, The Inheritance Cycle is still my favorite series

(Except for The Final Storm, Book III of The Door Within Trilogy)

And no, it doesn't get them off the fansites. The Inheritance Forums (13,000 members) has moderator anti's, for instance. No wonder I hate that particular one . Also, a lot of people I thought I knew were anti's, I discovered on Seventh Element (No links, people!), where a thread was named "WHY DOES HE DO THIS TO US?!" Notice the improper grammar there: You can only have an exclamation or a question mark, not both in a sentence.

1. grammar doesn't matter that much!!! lol...

2. caterpillar!!! THEY ARE WORSE THAN I THOUGHT!!! THANK YOU FOR ENLIGHTENING ME!!! SO THEY AGREE WITH ANTI SHURTUGAL AND THEY HAVE MODS WHO ARE ANTIs?!?!?!

it matters. trust me.

of course its not perfect, nothing is, but it was still a very good book.



and that's a very good book, and series!!

anyways, I still feel that it's obsession, and rather pointless. each to his own, but....

So, nothings perfect.

tell me why u think its not perfect...
I dont think anythings perfect but I still want to here why u people dont think its perfect.

crazy

Please don't spam, xwon3. I encourage you to read the rules Here

In addition, xwon3, please do not resurrect old threads.

Closed.

Most forums nowdays have this rule: it's actually quite appropriate, I think.

If you have any further questions, please PM me.

Sincerely

Sauron.
----

Locked