Im with Good Charlotte all the way

It would be hard to choose. I say both, or neither.

Never heared Good Charlotte so go Greenday go!

How can you have not heard of Good Charlotte...? Try downloading 'the motivation proclamation'... some guy gave to me, it is the best song

I'm with both!!!!

I only like the song from good charlotte anthem but i like all the songs on American idiot so Greenday

How in the world do you conpare those 2 bands ok there both great but they arnt exactly in the same leage r they??? Greenday Rulz All The WAY!!!!!!!!!!

Wait was that that storytellers thing???

How could you pick between the two??? Good Charolette is an awesome band but so is GreenDay. . . . . .

i haven't heard much of good charlotte so i say greenday!
even though there latest album is really depressing

I don't like Good Charlotte really. They're ok, I just wouldn't listen to them more than once a week. So, Green Day all the way!

green day how can you compare the two green day proved they got what it takes to stay for the long haul i dont think good charlet will be round very long

Proved what it takes to stay for the long haul? nah, they just became emo and made happier heavier music.

i like the chronicals of life and death and american idiot

neither!

wat are you talking about
anyway they are both great songs
i also like
hoilday
wake me up when september ends

and thats why i voted green day

I like alot of Green Day's older songs

i never heard them but i know they have been around for about 10years

Yeah, thier older songs are really good though. I like thier new album American Idiot too.

GreenDay rocks all the way, and plus Billie Joe is really cute!!!!

Cant forget Tre'!!!!!! Lol, one of my fav. songs is Basketcase {from G.D}

Definitely Green Day- Boulevard of broken dreams is amazing, American Idiot rocks, Wake Me up When September ends and Homecoming are really sad As in emotional, not pathetic lol! See the extract in my sig?

Edit: No you don't because it's not there any more lol

good charlotte is a really good band, but I'm not so democratic. i like green day, but not to the point where it beats GC

green day's an awesome band.

green day because of the american idiot songs like holiday

both of nothing

Old school Green Day is so much better than American Idiot and even that is better than Good Charlotte, but Good Charlotte is ok, jsut not compared to Green Day

Excatly, I think the same thing. Just don't compare them, green day is going to win in the end.

green day rox

Yes, they rock my socks off!!!!!

Both of them have some pretty good songs

I like Good Charlotte better. that Japenese thing at the begining is cool. The Battle Between Life And Death.

I dont like Green Day cause they swear too much.

but, whatever blows your hair back.

green day is way beter

greenday

Both of them suck ;(

Green day.

Good Charlotte for me. I got sick of Green Day last year when their song "Wake me up when September ends" is being overplay to the point where I got real sick of it. ((no offence))

Green Day were cool until I discovered real metal

Green Day is overrated and Good Charolette is underrated, right now i'd have to say GC cuz i've heard enough about Green Day to last me a long time

haha. True. Green Day is so over-rated to the point of me being sick about it.

Amen. They are like the prep band now :/. I like the old GD more..

GREEN DAY!!!!