who would win between Legolas, Gimli, Gandalf the White, Aragorn, Treebeard, and Pippin

p.s. sorry i forgot treebeard in the poll, i wish i could change it

That would be either Gandalf the White or Aragorn. If Gandalf used his Istari powers, then he would win!

dude, legolas would shoot all the people with his bow

when I read the begining of the 2nd book Gandalf sad with the fellowship non of your weppons coud hurd me

but gandalf can deflect legosasis arrows he did it before.

We havent decided what weapons, what armor, what positionsthey would be in.

Gandalf hands down.

nah, treebeard the ent would just squish everyone

upps I meant in 2nd book

Gandalf the White would just use magic to catch the ent on fire and then the Ent wouldn't be able to find any water and he'd burn.

I got a question. Of all the hobbits why didn't you choose Frodo, pippin sucks but frodo at least has the ring.

But I am sure Gandalf could win if he beat the Belrog.

Yeah Gandalf had defeated the Balrog. An Ent wouldn't have bean able to get near him of fear of catching on fire.

Gandalf rocks. What more is there to say? If they were all fully equipped, he can use magic. No competition at all

Firetongue's right. Gandalf has magic, so no one really can defeat him. There probably wouldn't be too much of a battle.

gandalf could kill every member in the fellowship. hes very powerfull becous he wiated to go to the next stage in his life after he killed the balrog. wizards are beings made out of magic. their, specal with inate knowledge of the world becous a wizard is made of magic, magic surrounds everything so inturn, he knows alot about everything. and sence he killed a balrog he could take on everyone and win.

if veryne worked together gandalf would die and then out of poeple left legolas would win

gandalf would still win.

I agree with that. If Gandalf (and Treebeard) wasn't there, Legolas would most definately win.

acording to the votes your mistaken.

I didn't vote.

over all i mean.

well Gimli, Aragorn, and legolas have already tried ganging up on gandalf(thinking he was sauruman) and still lost. Not to mention with pippin's help he would probably screw something up. the only thing that could possibly help is treebeard and he is pretty slow if you recall.

Aragorn will win! He's my fav character and he's king and king have a biiiiiiiig army

OK lets take gandalf out of this

good idea

Of the remaining people I think Aragorn would win because he is the best swordfighter

If we took Gandalf out I would say Treebeard.

I think Legolas would win because he could just shoot everyone with arrows.

did you know that treebeard is realy fangorn?

Arrows wouldn't hurt Treebeard. He's made out of wood.

I forgot about Treebeard.
He would stomp on all of them

legolas

But Mutagh Legolas arrow wouldn't be able to hurt Treebeard, he's made out of wood.

he could use fire arrows

That could work, but what it Treebeard stomps him?

Legolas could probably dodge Treebeard if he tried to stomp him. After all, he's an elf.

exactly
then legolas would watch treebeard run around on fire
" ha i made an ent hurry, wat now"

treebeard would win in the end because he would get mad, bellow, and get other ents to help him step o legolas

legolas could bring some other elfs and wat if treebeard died from the fire

There ARE no other ents.

yeah there are

NO, you don't get what I mean!!!! I mean this is a showdown between Legolas, Treebeard, Aragorn, and all the other characters. It wouldn't be fair adding characters.

Aragorn could summon the Army of the Dead and they would kick ***!!! If it was a sword/axe fight, then Aragorn would win because he has Anduril. Legolas has his sissy knifes, Pippin has a short sword from the creepy dude in the forest that Tom Bombadil gives to him after he loses it (that's not much of a help). Without Fangorn or Gandalf, Aragorn would win in a sword fight!

Don't you mean Treebeard? Without those two I think Legolas would win, Not Aragorn.

Yeah. Legolas can just shoot everyone with arrows, and doesn't even have to get into close combat.

Yeah they'd be dead before they even got anywhere.

exactly

Aragorn would win cause while legolas is trying to kill all the other guys Aragorn could use his bow(I think that fact most people forget) and shoot legolas. His aim may not be as good as legolas but it would suffice

aragorn would never hit someone from behind

Besides, Legolas could just shoot Aragorn first.

I think Legolas would choose Aragorn first.

I said in a sword/axe fight, Aragorn would win hands down. ANDURIL KICKS ***!!!

In a sword/axe battle yeah, maybe. But in a archer's contest Legolas would take the trophy.

Duh, he's an elf!!! Elves are the best in archery!!! Wait, it'd be a tie between Aragon and Gandalf in a sword fight!!! I CAN'T CHOOSE!!!

Gandalf's pretty good with a sword, it could be a tie.

I dont know what yall are talking about Legolas is hot and he is an awsome archer. Plus he is an elf.

We're talking about axe to sword. Not archering. Have you seen the new POTC. I haven't, we could've if we'd have dressed up like Pirates to the premiere.

If it was in helms deep with shields everywhere, Legolas would own lol. Rember the battle of helms deep?

yep the battle of helms deep is my fav. The ent war rocks as well. I totaly agree legolas would rule. are you a boy or a girl

Ummm, boy? On topic please

All of your arguments are convincing, but I say that Gollum would win because he would sneak up a kill everybody in their sleep.

But legolas could trick him by throwing the ring off of the helms deep tower, andgollum would die jumping after it. or he could just shoot him while he falls.

Yeah that's true. He'd be so in to that ring he'd follow it anywhere.

When did Legolas get the ring????

This is a showdown, anything could happen. Besides, Gollum isn't even supposed to be in this.

If gandalf got the ring, watch out!

dude, gandalf left, so hes not in it anymore

That's the point...nobody expects him to sneak in so he takes everyone by surprise!!

If I remember correctly, Gandalf didn't want the ring in the first place.

ok i mean he is not part of the discussion anymore

Then Legolas would win, if Treebeard is still in then he'd win though.

trebeard is in it, but legolas would shoot him with fire arrows and then he would burn

But Treebeard would break the watergate and he would cool off.

then once the water was gone, he would get shot with fire arrows all over again

wow I think we should apply some scenarios here like what weapons the people are given, the setting, whether or not they are all in full health, etc. etc.

OK, they are on a flat field. They are only allowed to use melee weapons. Gandalf can't use magic. Fangorn is out because he can step on everybody, which isn't fun! Basically, Aragorn has Anduril, Gandalf has his staff and his sword, whose name starts with a G, Legolas has his (sissy) knives, Gimli has his waraxe, and Merry has his shortsword.

Aragorn or Gandalf will win.

OK, they are on a flat field. They are only allowed to use melee weapons. Gandalf can't use magic. Fangorn is out because he can step on everybody, which isn't fun! Basically, Aragorn has Anduril, Gandalf has his staff and his sword, whose name starts with a G, Legolas has his (sissy) knives, Gimli has his waraxe, and Merry has his shortsword.

Aragorn or Gandalf will win.

WHAT IS WRONG WITH THIS SIGHT TODAY???!!!

Legolas has to have a bow too; that's his main weapon.

We are talking Melee weapons!!! Melee weapons only!!! Otherwise, Gandalf would be allowed to use his magic, then Gandalf would win!!!

yes but then it is an unfair advantage. they should all get their main weapons aside from magic. And treebeard should be allowed

I guess that'd be fair. Also Gandalf's weapon is called Glamdring.

ok fine legolas would have to use his double elven blades

They're ok. He's pretty fast with them.

ok, GANDALF WOULD OVER KILL EVERYTHING!

GANDALF KICKS @$$!!! If people get their ranged weapons, why can't Gandalf???

lightning bolts man. he can shoot lighning bolts.

gandalf will forsureeeeeeee

ok gandlaf now can only use his sword and staff, with NO magic, because now legolas would own him with the elven blades

Gandalf has Glamdring and his staff! All Legolas has are his sissy little knives!

dude, gandalf moves slow in his attacks though, so legolas would be dodging and stuff while slashing him

Yeah. Legolas is a lot faster than Gandalf.

ya, well gandalf doesnt have to be fast. he can just electrocute legolas and that would be the end of it.

No magic remember. It might be a draw. They can't beat each other because they're both too good.

yes but he has a very short range of attack with his daggers where gandalf has about twice as big of an attack range in order for legolas to get in that close he would have to sacrifice his defense opening the chance that Gandalf would cut him down. Besides gandalf is pretty fast especially considering how heavy his own sword is.

legolas has to of those swords that aruwen had in the first, they are normal length, and plus, gandalf seriously attacks at like 2mph

well, david beats goliath

okay you need to be quick with a sword in order to fight off several orcs like gandalf did. and his blades are normal length for a dagger but gandalf's sword is nearly twice as long.

NO, his blades are normal length for a sword, and in the third movie gandalf moves so slow. which is why pippin had to save him

have you even read the books? if legolas had strapped two regular sized blades to his back he wouldn't have been able to unsheath them because they would be too long. also gandalfs sword is a long sword wich means it is still longer than an average sized sword.