not to blow you down or anything but woldnt it be alot happening to Arya
if she became a rider and pregneant and it would be hard to fight in battle with a baby.

yes yes nethy's got a point (hi nethy!!) i still think its katrina

well i dont think shell become the rider untill the last book els the new dragon would be on the cover coz i think thats why each dragons on the cover when the book has something to do with it (eg saphira-born thorn-born ?gladrea-die?)

What if Shruakin dies though then would it have two dragons on iit?

i dunno if CP would do that. though it would look cool!!

it might have all the dragons on the last book...like the 3 new 1s anyway.

That would be awesome kinda difficult mabey if they were as large as Saphira and Thorn were on the book.

We should probably get back on topic...

She probably would be because I think at least three months have gone by.

Elva would have to get older still if she were to get pregnant. And she probably won't have to get older when Eragon removes the curse from her.

even if eragon reamoves the curse shes probably gonna die..most likely befor he does!!

because i think shes gonna die protecting some1 probably eragon that would be good irony!!

The chances are it is Katrina.

If Elva is cured from the curse how can she die protecting someone?

True, but if she is still stuck as a toddler she probably isn't going to be in the battle feild. Or she could sneak into it I suppose...

well she could die before the curse is lifted. or maby it doesnt work propally either way i think shes gonna die...katrina could be pregnant but then again it could be some1 we dont know yet...or arya??

Ok I reckon katrina is pregnant.. aparently cp said that someone was GOING to be preganant- so could that mean that someone actualy gets pregnant during brisingr??

cha probably thats what makes me think its soem1 we dont know!

Ummm, it is still Katrina. There are way too many proofs for that. Well, at least one proof, but it's enough to say she is.

I know it's unlikely, but i guess the pregnant may be Nasuada.
Katrina would be so predictable...
And then, CP said that in the third book the Varden may not trust her anymore, that something unexpected is going to happen to her and that he made some changes in this character.
Maybe i'm saying something stupid, but it would be more interesting than a Katrina's pregnancy..

The only one i was thinking about is Murtagh, but my idea is that they'll meet each others again in the next book and spend more time togheter
what do you think guys?

ok, but CP said that a character "becomes" pregnant
Katrina is pregnant already, if she's the person we are talking about

i think it would be interesting if it was nasuada because it would be more complicated...i love drama!!

the varen would go to cayos..blady bla..and theyde all live hapily ever after!!! i dont know what would happen in da middle!!

well i dont know..depends if it was her choise..also if he comes good they mite not be quite so pissed

see what you mean..it would be all around confusing...but i do hope murtagh goes good!!

Murtagh can't turn good, poor man, but he still can fall in love with a woman, the wrong woman.
I imagine that the Empire kidnaps Nasuada and she meets Murtagh again, so they fall in love
Then, Murtagh can't make her suffering anymore (sorry for my english.. ) and releases her
When they're apart, she knows she's pregnant
Paolini said that something surprising is going to happen to her at the end of the book. The only surprise i can imagine is a pregnancy or a dragon egg which hatches for her

I ask for your forgiveness guys but i'm not english speaking...i hope i've explained my idea well

ye thats ok with the writing...im english and i cant spell anyway!! i still hopes he turns good!! GOOD THEORIE!!

I don't think he will. I want him two, but if their are tow good dragons and two bad dragons the chances are Saphira will kill Shrukian and Greene will kill Thorn.

If Murtag does come to the Varden to see Nasuada wouldn't he be captured?

Wouldn't Nasuada attempt to have him captured though?

ye elva could probably see it coming but maby nasuada wouldnt get him captured coz its kinda obvious she likes him!!

did CP relly meen that to happpen or is your imagination filling the gaps
with its own crude details for i didnt get the notion that she liked him.

half and half...she did go n visit him when he was in the prison in fathen dur and she sounded upset when she was a rider with galby so fill in the gaps

i see your point sorry for my arrogance.

thats cool i am most of the time anyway!! lol jks

Maybe the King will send Murtagh in Surda again, to capture the Varden's chief.
He'll kidnap her and during the captivity they'll fall in love (it's not difficult i'm sure, they're already on the good way to do it)
Then, she will be release and when Murtagh is away, she discovers her pregnancy...good or bad?

would be interesting...could happen if eragon went back 2 eles which is likely (good theory!)

it's just a theory...maybe i'm wrong and the pregnant is Katrina, what a boring plot...just my opinion..

Its good, but not too likely.

If Katrina was pregnant Galby could use the baby against the Varden and Surda.

interesting...im confused

impossilble for eragon is going to lift the spell and elva will go back to a baby for only the magic that saphira and eragon gave her is makeing her grow.

and we already disscussed this didnt we?

yeah we did but it was only that she was gonna die pretty much
i agree with Brinny
i dont think she's gonna go back to being a baby
and i think that a bit of the magic will still kinda linger and Elva will still grow up fast and then she gets pregnant then the baby takes on elva's ability to grow fast and then...this is gonna sound crazy but...it becomes the next dragon rider
oh and the guy will be an elf so the baby is half elf so it will be a good fighter

i know it sounds crazy but i just had a bunch of ice cream so im a bit loopy =)


why does everyone think she's gonna die? u guys r so optimistic!

this is kinda off topic but exactly hoow much icecream did you have? please no more!


and i didnt say elva would die i just said the spell wold be lifted and she would be a baby again! and of story good bye the end!!!

(a LOT! and it was good =)...double chocolate)

why and how do u think she'll go back to being a baby? i dont get it!

oh i love that kind!

and like all the magic stuff will drain from her and like every week shell get a year younger or sometin. i dunno but she will not stay the same age,

oh my god can i have some icecream!!!??? i had chok milk n a cookie so im equally as hyper!!

i think elva will die but only because anyone who is remotely good, in books, usually dies!! lol

sry, its all gone!

that makes sense, i just hope she doesnt die
i hate it when people die!

not the only one!!


why no more icecream???

what do you think about maud becoming pregnant. If not maud i hope its saphira.

i dont think maud is an important enough character to get pregnant
we only met her once or twice and we dont know much about her
can werecats even get pregnant?

I guess the fight is between Katrina and Nasuada

mostly yeah, but i think elva is a possablitly but nobody else does
shaphira has been mentioned a few times but its unlikely in my opinion

why do you have icecream in a paintball shooter?



and i never thought of maud becomeing pregnant and i think shes an important enough character if werecats can even become pregnant.

once again every1 is ignorin red shurtual dude!! hi by da way!! i think elvas too young to get pregnant tho...saphira couldnt because gladr wouldnt and if she did it would have 2 be thorn and i dam well hope that doesnt happen less murtag turns good....i dont know...i would love it 2 b arya!! would be interesting!!

yeah i like the idea of elva being pregnant, i think she's gonna have a pretty big part in the next book (i will laugh in all yur faces when she does =) remember she can make herself grow faster then normal? so she's gonna grow up real fast get pregnant then her kid will be the next dragon rider, like i said in an earlier post that no one really responded too!

and yes...red DOES have a paintball shooter loaded with ice cream...BEWARE!

ok icecream paintball shooter..hmmmmmmm....tasty!!

it would be cool if elva go pregnant but no i likely...thats my opinion anyway

and it hard to get noticed around here what does a girl have to do to get a responce???!!!!

eheh and elva is gonna get pregnant with who?

dunno maybe eragon? i would laf so hard ha ha ha

okay nobody has answered my question!!
why is there icecream in a paint ball shooter?????

well what ever i dont think elva will become pregnant i just have this feeling that she wont!

has anyone thouht that izlandzadie could be the pregnant one????

just a guess.

she's too old !
And it's already a miracle she has had Arya, if you consider how rares are elven children

anyone wanna consider the possibility of an unkown character becoming pregnant, its unlikely and i feel stupid as i type these words

stupid (and sick and twisted ) theroy #2:
That somehow a guy become preggers.

im very bored right now and im gunna have trouble waiting 30 more days

hahaha!! that would be funny....

i no bout the text talk confusin or wat??? ha now i am!! lol

i think nasuada!!

ok i JUST read tha bit in eldest.... and it sed roran DISROBED and got into bed..........and katrina came in...then the soldiers and ra'zac cum im amd katrina LIFTS THE BLANKET OVER HER BODY. and me and arya_rox4lyfe hav discussed this ov and ova... and she reckons nasuada has feelings 4 murtagh, and i payed close attention and wen murtagh woz in his cell he sed that nasuada seemed nice and kind and evrythin.. and eragon pushed 'the thought' from his hed............interestin. also cp shocks us by writing down the most least likely things eva.........

thats what makes me think its nasuada!!!!!! eeelf (every 1 but baby elf ignor that)

what chapter was it coz i have a different copy of eldest and its about 1000 pgs. coz its shorter than the other one

what chapter is that because i'm re reading eldest for like the 6th time and I don't remember that. And besides if you cant get engaged without asking for permission i don't think that they could DO IT without geting married.

how many times hove u read it??

Sorry, but i guess you have missed Roran's chapters, it's impossible you didn't notice that part after 6 times

6 times...iv only read it 2

I get bored here and that is the only thing that I can really do. I'll try to find it later today. But it seems unlikely to me that roran and katrina would go that far without marriage just givin the traditions of their town.

um....if you havnt noticed theve kinda already messed big style with the traditions....dont think they care anymore!!!

yeh arya's rite.... and evryone thinks its gonna b katrina anyway.......but until they rescue her - we dont no 4 sure!!

woo go me im special!!!! i still katrinas gona die!!! if im right you have to bow down b4 me

I finally found it, its in the chapter his enemies face. Yeah we wont know for sure untill the third book comes out.

what???


it sucks coz every1 comes up with there own theories and we fight then they never happen in the book

mayb we should make a list of possibl candidates:
*katrina
*nasuada
*arya
*saphira (ok maybe, only if last dragon hatches)
*Odele (that friend of katrina's although it isnt likely)
*Trianna
*angela
*that dwarf lady orik woz gonna marry (hvedra or sumthin)
anyone else??
and also do u guys reckon elain's gonna hav a girl or boy??

hmmmm....boy...then it would be 3 boys lol poor elain!!!

tnx for the info. i saw it. i think that katrina is going to be pregnant. that may probably explain why roran is really desperate to rescue her whatever the odds. I think.

Ok, but Roran doesn't know she's pregnant, if she is.

your all wrong wrong i tell you....

it wont be katrina coz that is the most obvious thing and i think we know by now the most obvious thing doesnt usually happen

it could be anyone. but I hope its saphira still.

hmmmm would be cool but still unlikely

it us unfortunately. maybe its maud the werecat

na i recon she wud b an awsome mother!!

yeah the obvious and logical choice is katrina but it doesnt feel right; just too predictable. on the other hand roran is pimp and having a little family to care for would be good for him. but CP never says at what point in the book the char gets pregnant. also CP said he is going to introduce a lot more characters in brisingr so while katrina is the most possible its by no means a lock.

yeh, whiskeyjack is rite,

u dont who will get preganant.and it could be one of the new characters. cant wait!! the wait is over for me in 4 days!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!1