Well that is an idea that i got from Glenwing. What do you think is the weapon under the menoa tree?

probly not sumthing u would think of right away like a sword or bow...
probly sumthing that would only b useful at a certain point in time

im thinking the elf eragon's sword or vraels sword perhaps

thats actually a pretty good idear
it would totally make sence

i guess, although more likely eragon's sword coz vrael probly used it b4 he died

sry i cant remember who vrael is...
but now that ive read eldest i understand y there would b a sword

Well, at the end of Eldest Murtagh takes Zar'Roc from Eragon, so yea either the elf Weapons Smith(i forgot her name) is going to make a blue sword for him or i think that vrael's sword or some kind of weapon is under the meoa tree. Perhaps a scroll of REALLY powerful and forbidden magic

ya ur probly right
of course it would make more sence after u read the eldest y he would get a sword

yup, he woodnt ever use forbidden magic apart from in exceptional circimstances. It is this that seperates him from galbotorix and Murtague. Vrael probably had it at Doru Arabea when he was killed, so Eragon's is a best bet...what ever happened to him anyway? did he just die or go away or something?

im not sure...

i bet its eragons sword..the old elf eragon

yea thats wut i think cuz like they have the same name and there kinda in the same position were the whole of alagasia rests in their hands

yeah... exactly wat i was trying to say

lol

or probably he finds broms sword...brom lost his sword, and his dragon was also called saphira

brom sword was probably destroyed when he lost his dragon, so it could not have been that. It might not be the most obvious thing.

yea i think its either eragons or broms

no i think broms sword is still intact. Morzan died, so obviously his dragon died too, but zarroc was still perfect..

i thought that the swords are indestucable

Maybe by normal means, but with magic..... maybe.

maybe....but istill think that it might b broms

yeah, swords would be destructable otherwise there would be lots ofold swords lying around everywhere from previous riders..i think brom just lost his

yea cuz like when that elf that makes the swords wuz talking about brom it souded like he lost his sword it didn't sound like it got desroyed

The elf says that there were only 3 swords left..zarroc, galbatorix's sword and oromis' sword

i think she meant the swords that are not lost or desrtoyed

Just a guess but it could be some sort of scroll to free Murtagh from his magic bound with Galbatorix seeming as he was forced to promise alliegance.

but it sed that i would be a weapon and dosen't have a sword ne so i think he is gonna get a new 1 that would probly b in da vault of souls not under the menona tree

she sed there where only 3 swords that they knew of but yea i think that its is either eragon(the elf) or brom's sword

yeah...thats wat i meant

Yeah im so excited...hehe

the vault of souls were prebably all teh dead riders souls that galbotorix killed. They probably teach eragon some of the spells.

yea probly or sumthing like that

or it could be something crazy like a curved katana or like a mace that would be .... lol o o o o or an ice pick!!!

ice pick? where did u get that idea from?

i think he just thought up sumthing random

ur damn right i did lol but i think a sword or a spell is too boring it should be some unorthadox weapon of mass destruction like an ice pick!

lol u act like this kid onmy bus named john he likes random things 2 like the nick name he gave me frito thats my nick name every1 @ skool calls me it lol but it is rlly random lol

yeah..somepeple are like that..they just do something totaly unexpected..anyway......vault of souls probably just give eragon experioence wat tto watch out for when being attacked by magic users...or galbotorix, not necessarily a weapon

yea if there is a weapon then it would b undre the menona tree

No offence but hasn't anyone realised he's already found it? When the spirits from the menoa tree make him like an elf: he finds a weapon.

the elf eragons sword most likly couase it would probaly not be known about by much couase he was hiding the fact that he was a dragon rider nad he probaly made it himself. the real question is what is it made of? its probaly made of somthing real wierd like dragon egg shells or dragon scales etc.

i don't think so cuz it seys sumthing like if u r in need of a weapon u eill find 1 umder the rootes of the menona tree and it wuz more like the spirits of the dragons from saphira oromisis dragon(i forgot his name) and just the spirt from maybe like just in du weldevarden but not from the menona tree

i think that the name of the ancient language is under the meneo tree and eragons name is in the vault of souls. But i m probably wrong. and i think that the elf smith that stopped making the swords will make one more

is the transformation to an elf (both phisical and strength) can be consider as a weapon? But remember, Zar'roc' is now gone! Umm... Eragon promised oromis to return to Ellesmera to complete his training (i don't know if that means AFTER he beats galbatorix but i think such thing is absurd), so maybe he'll find another strong weapon from under the menoa tree once he gets back. It makes sense, ya!

I couldn't of said a better guess nice!

yea but zar'roc gone & he needs a sword

I think it will be eragon's old sword...I mean the elf. Wait he was the first dragon rider write?

yea

what color was thats elfs dragon enyway. and i also wonder if the sword might have some sort of power mabye he will like get to meet eragon the elf in like a vision or something like that.

yea i think the dragon wuz silver or blue or white sumthing like that

white sounds about right

yea

i couldnt even imagine that a white dragon imagine the camoflague in the clouds or the snow

yea it would b rllly kool

i wonder if enybody went blind from starring at a dragon in the sun for to long

lol idk

I'm lost in this conversation lol how did it get to that? lol

idk lol ok wut wuz the main topic of this topic ??? i 4got lol

we got there by talking about the color of eragon the elfs dragon

Blue anyone? lol maybe with a hint of white? one lope or two? roflmao

ok well the topic is wuts under the menona tree so yea i think its eragons sword!!!!!!!!!!!

eragons new's sword or eragon old sword

the first eragons sword

okay well i think it might be a shield

well i think its sum kinda of weapon lol i'm bing very vaug and stating the ovious lol i'm bored

yeah for like the 12 time tonight i find it fun to compete and try to get the newest post

Eragon d first's dragon is white! remember islanzadi told (before the oath celebration i think but im not sure though) about the [pact after du vrangr skulblaka] between Eragon elf and a "WhiTe dragon whos name r not suppose to tell" or i get it wrong dunno -- get back to d'topic i'm happie to y'all agree it's a weapon indeed

a shieldwould be sooooo cool. and his sword can come from the smith

i think that a new sword will be under the menoa tree and that the vault oh souls will contain all the knowledge of the dead riders, or a way to talk to them

The elf smith swore not to make a new weapon , but here's something, will Eragon return just to find the weapon, or maybe to finish his training, or maybe any number of other reasons

no shill do something for him she has to cp wouldnt of put her in book 2 just to get rid of her

Maybe its some kinda of cool metal that if you speak the true name of the weapon you need it'll form the weapon to fit you exactly.

Okay, whoever said that it is a shield is an idiot! it said it would be a weapon under the Menoa tree!!!!

hey a shield is a weapon. its just defensive instead of ofensive

lol....a shield is not a weapon a shield is a shield lol....its a tool of defence not a weapon. anyways, It will most definitly be a sword I am guessing becaus he is now lacking one.

yea i think its a sword but i guess a sheild could b a weapon if u used it lke 1 but if u use it properly then its not a weapon

Vrael died, he was the only one who could with stand the power of the forswan and Galbatroix. When he finally beat Galbatroix he hesitated with the final blow. There Glaby did something and Vrael was forced to leave. But Galby found him and at that time Galby kicked Vraels something and gained the victory and it was then that Galby anounced himself kink of Aligaziea (Sp)

i think he ment whut happened 2 da elf eragon

The elf dragon rider? He died, because at that time the elves had not made themselves immortal. So he died.

whoa but the dragons where immortal. and if they signed the treaty he gianed the power remeber.

What if its another dragon egg? That would certainly be a strong weapon, and then they could actually match Galby and Mutagh...and even if te original Eragon hadn't died of old age, Galby would have killed him. I'm voting on another dragon egg, that would be a POWERFUL weapon.

i agree with this! But as for a dragon egg.. umm.. it would bring lots of dragons into the game! glaedr saphira shruikan thorn the-unhatched-green-dragonegg-in-galbatorx-castle and new egg from under mecoa tree??? Confuse confuse; instead of green cover it would be a rainbow cover then lol

it will definetely be a white sword because it will be elf eragons old wepon and elf eragons dragon was white

i would say its ethier a new sword for eragon from maybe the sword lady w/e her name is,vraels old sword, broms sword(eragon and brom had a connection), or the first rider eragon sword. i just cant wait to find out.

We should all find a religion and PRAY really hard that CP puts it out early!

yea really, and u know how u can take off spells like the 1 eragon put on elva, and eragons teacher told him that if u undo the spell it is more powerful than someone else trying to take it off.

i think it's the first eragon's sword

u never know

ya

i hope its a blue sword to match the color of saphira

yep that sounds cool

no not cool, that would be freakin awsome

ya lol

yea

blue sword would be so cool that way it would match saphira

yea because that old grandma lady made swords for the riders but the problem is she took an oath not to make another weapon again so that really sucks

ya it does, maby she'll break her oath, if she didn't say it in the ancient language

see theres the problem she made the oath in the ancient language but she might be able to stop it

oooooooo ouch!!!

yea that really sucks