did u just say the exact same thing as u said b4??? isnt that consitered double posting??? i dunno.

there's another thing too..elves are'nt exactly very clear on their feelings and again Arya would never have a baby with Eragon...that would just be disgusting..besides, i dont think CP has enough pages left to like get in Arya and Eragon having a baby

well, they could definately get into a relationship. and CP could make an epilouge like 6 months later , with Arya pregnant.

even if he did make an epilogue, it would be simply an abomination..Eragon would be much too young and I do not think that Saphira would be a likely candidate to help him out in wisdom..i mean there would be matters on which even saphira would be blank, for Arya is indeed very experienced..and recieving wisdom from another is indeed an abomination

NO NO NO NO NO!!!! Arya said that her sharing HER experiences is an abomination. Eragon and Saphira's minds are connected by a special bond. they live in each others' minds as much as their own. they share EVERYTHING! including Saphira's wisdom.

and Eragon would be much too young for what?

he would'nt be able to comprehend half of whatever Saphira would say..I mean take the glade for example..he could hear evrything but he could'nt COMPREHEND everything..Arya probably is wise enough to comprehend that and more..in THAT way he is far too young...
and I dont think that Arya would like Saphira answering questions that were aimed at Eragon

what are you talking about?????? he can comprehend everything! but some of the stuff was hidden b/c it is Dragon-only info. and she wouldn't answer for him. which questions are you talking about??? it has nothing to do with the context.

well take it this way..
Eragon and Arya have two completely different ways of thinking..where he comprehends light, she may comprehend the light to be an omen for an upcoming era of darkness..they cannot be together..atleast not until Galby is dead for that is Eragon's most imp task and Arya will not hamper it

hey! have you ever heared that opposites atract?

i think that Ayra doesn't love him, once again i'll say it, she said she doesn't love him in the AL. it should be simple to understand

i thought so too, but is possible that she does have feelings for him deep down, but she doesn't realize it, or understand it. so thusly she can say she doesnt because she believes what she says to be true.

that's true, i would say that Ayra needs Eragon to stop pestering her, that would help her understand it. i mean, who wants to love a pain?

lol. well, she seems to chage by the end of the book, so maybe she has started to realize it alredy!

if only CP would tell us something about the book... is CP in the forum?

but even if he was he woudnt, cus that would ruin the big suspense of the book

yeah... we r getting off topic, aren't we?

yeah! i do think that this topic should have a poll... most of the time we would be ON topic...

I think that if Eragon and Arya had a kid it would be AWESOME! But, you have to consider that they have such hectic lives that a child could cause a distraction not to mention what Islanzadi would think of it. {sighing with frustration}! Though that kind of relationship would be so awesome, so hot, so lovey! I'm siked.....

**********************************************************************************
The sword wizzed past Nim's head, missing him by inches. "You doubt my control?", asked Lux listlessly.

i'm not saying they need 2 have one during the normal corse of the book, but like her getting on the boat, pregnant. that kind of assurance. that would be awsome!

i don't think they will, it's not gonna happen, i just don't. i mena, she MAY love him deep underneath, but she said she didn't in the AL, as i said higher up, who would love a pain in the neck?

Me neither I really don't think she will truly show her emotions to him at all.

book three has many possibility's that would be a definite longshot

yeah, hes right, theres no way that could happen, i mean Ayra is like a hundred years old and Eragon is like 16

always people are bringing up the age thing

if they love each other, do you really think that age will matter?

The first one to bring it up was Ayra in the chapter, Under the Menoa Tree. Besides when Eragon was reading about the history of Riders and Elves, I believe CP mentioned something about how the relationships between humans and Riders did not have a happy ending. (Can't quote, not at home!!) :roll:

Sweet justice, THANK YOU Anniebee.

I know not a lot of peoople are for the Nasuada\Eragon theory but there are a LOT of people AGAINST the Arya\Eragon theory. I'd be happy if they just don't get together. Nasuada geting together with him is just a plus.

I don't know how many times I've said here, there and everywhere. The idea of Ayra and Eragon together churns my stomach!!! I find it to be morally wrong, repugnant and unfair to Eragon.
I may be thinking in terms of a Mom, an adult, or whatever! The idea just makes me want to puke!!!!!

Stop saying such beautiful things, your making me love you!!!!!!!!

Okay one more time. I like knowing I'm not the only one hating that ccouple witch I dare not post. If I do, I'll jynx it.

So you don't follow the Nasuada\Eragon belief?

I think that was something that Eragon learned from a scroll that Oromis gave him. But hey! none of the previous human riders were transformed, saved the elf they love, and are Alagaesia's last hope! PLUS they (Eragon and Saphira) have done what noone else has done countless times. what then is keeping them from having the first lasting human/elf relationship?!

OHHHH!!!!! i just thought of another great point!!! Remember when Eragon found out that Arya was a princess? Saphira said that Arya didn't change, just his perception of her. Same thing with the age thing, except for OUR perception of her has changed. Why was it ok b4 we knew and wrong now? Arya hasn't changed!

majorly wise!

I SO THINK ARYA LOVES ERAGON!!! but in the way you love your best friend!

I dont think they will EVER EVER EVER get together!!! atleast i hope they dont...i dont think they will because > 1. age 2. i think arya might of had a child with faolin 3. because I said that they arent allowed!!!
[/i]

i agree with curious_liv

I think she does love him and they probably won't have kid but they may runaway together for a night or two. SOOOO romantic, wish I was her! {groan}



Find your Celestial Choir
**********************************************************************************

The sword wizzed past NIm's head, missing him by inches. "You doubt my control?", Lux asked listlessly.

I think they'll get together
there may be a lord of the rings thing
like aragorn and Arwen
i don't think they'll have a kid
but she might get pregnant

a kid would be aquard in the book. but i think pregnant counts. the point is, will they love each other to that degree?

wow ive been off of thing 4 along time b/c the last time i got on i only had 70 replies and now ive git 136 lol

and you seem to have forgotten how to stay on topic! lol.

i've never met you bandbunny, but have seen people with the sig "put bandbunny in you signature for world domination!' so i guess your well know by others... anyway, back on topic, i don't think she will, i don't see anyway for it to work if she dies

lol sry ok on topic- i think arya will at least be pregnant at the end of the 3rd book, as so many of u have already mentioned - sry have 2 go back off topic- world domination? no i just used that name cause im n my highschool's 2006 marching band and im n jazz band and its better than sayin band geek lol

ah, i see now, look it the topic "Ayra Dieing?" and look in it, you'll find those with that in their sig. Well, back onto topic, i think that they may have a baby, then Ayra dies

now THAT is impractical. i don't think that even if she was put under the same conditions as Eragon was in during the Blood-Oath ceremony, with him intoxicated with magic, that she would be THAT stupid. That HAS to happen AFTER they beat Galby.

well, after then, IF she doesn't die

ok. she ISN'T GOING TO DIE!!!!! WHY WOULD SHE DIE???!!! IT WOULD BRING NOTHING GOOD TO THE BOOK!!!!!

it would make Eragon that much more likely to kill Galbatorix

like he wasn't going to before!!!

he would have more reason to kill Galbatorix

he has PLENTY of reason!

but that would give him more reason

Actualy he has plenty of reason to kill the Ra'zac and had plenty of reason to kill Durza. He doesn't really have a big beef with Galby beyond the dragon egg witch he wouldn't hate Galb for because they both want it for the same thing.

so you agree with me? someone agrees with me!!

1. killing thousands of people

2. destroying the riders and dragons

3. it's his fault that the Ra'zac killed Garrow and Brom in the first place!!!

4. Ayra was killed by Galabtorix himself

i don't want her to die, just brainstorming

why would galby kill her he has no reason 2 at all- the only reason he would have 2 kill her is if shes a rider which u dnt agree w/ so....

By killing the elves, he defeats the only force that could one day stop him with enough fighters. Not counting Eragon of course. It's probably a huge slaughter while Arya's at Ellesmera for something.

yea but galby is gonna eventually find out that eragon loves her since he makes it so obvious- murtagh probably even picked up on that i bet- so i doubt he'll kill her- may b use her as bait 2 lure eragon 2 him or somethin dramatic like that though

who all is on my band on Ayra dieing????? put something about Ayra dieing to show you agree with me!!!

I do.

I see it now, head bitten straight off...by Saphira. I think Arya is evil.

what!???????? what makes u think that! u hav 2 have reasons 2 believe these things cause any one can speculate things like that happening - give me reasons 2 believe that she will die not just shes gonna die and thats the end of it , whose w/ me!?

How many times must I type this. No matter what I post, no matter what you post, no mattter what Paolini posts, IT IS ALL SPECULATION!!!

yes but speculation based on facts- if u read imnc's sig he has given lots of good reasons why arya will b the next rider and he has proven it well 2

yeah, so suck THAT Shadowagent!!! lol. i had to say that.

speculation is always based on facts. what we call what you have posed is a "crack-pot theory".

if Ayra was evil, why would the Elves still be there? wouldn't Galbatorix have already known?

How is Arya evil? She's not evil or else she would've told Galbatorix everything when she was in prison because she hated everyone.

No, they staged it all for her to be with Eragon. To see if there was any evil in him. After she found out there wasn't any evil in him, she was stuck pretending to be his friend. Murtagh's evil to. She didn't phase when he came into the room while they thought he was dead. And, that explains why she's so forward about not liking. She's trying to anger him, and turn him against elves. And as for not telling where the elves live, she hadn't been home in 70 years. I'm sure she didn't know the exact location. Plus the elves probably have to swear in the ancient language not to give Ellesmera's location away to those who meant harm.

Murtagh's confused not evil. Because she knew he was alive because she went looking for him and saw that he was dragged away that's why she wasn't phased. No she's not, she's shy that's why. Because I bet her memory was wiped or she forget it on purpose so Galby wouldn't get it if Galby tried to probe her mind. And I agree she probably swore in the AL never to tell anyone where Ellesmera was if she ever was caught.

She didn't know Eragon was alive! That's Murtagh you're thinking of.

When what book are you talking about and what part?

In Eldest, when Eragon\Saphire where fighting Murtagh\Thorn, they couldn't contact Eragon, and got the idea that he was killed. When he came in, Arya didn't make a single move. She just sat where she was.

this is way off topic ur suppossed 2 b tlking about will they have a child!

Anyway she didn't flinch because she knew that he was still alive because he was dragged off not killed.

And hopefully they will have a child. I hope so.

i hope not teht would be strange

How would that be strange?

"The candle still burns," Arya murmured.

she was 1. surprised and 2. i think that she just learned of the depth of her feeling for him, thinking him dead, then seeing him alive again. she maskes her feeling a little too well. she does not even respond as a friend would, but less. she IS his friend. that is made clear. so she must be over-hiding someting.

i surprise myself sometimes, coming up with new thoughts and explinations. this one i think is a keeper!

THAT'S MURTAGH! SHE SAW THAT MURTAGH WAS DRAGGED OFF AND NOT KILLED! ARE YOU AT THE BEGINING OF THE BOOK? DO YOU THINK I'M SAYING SHE DIDN'T MOVE WHEN THEY FOUND OUT MURTAGH WAS ALIVED?

THE BOOK SAID THAT THEY ALL JUST ASSUMED ERAGON HAD BEEN KILLED! ARYA DIDN'T KNOW! SHE DIDN'T KNOW ERAGON WAS DRAGGED OFF! ERAGON WASN'T EVEN DRAGGED OFF! HE FLEW OVER AND FOUGHT MURTAGH! SHE THOUGHT ERAGON WAS DEAD, AND WHEN HE WALKED IN, WHAT DID ARYA DO? NOTHING!

And therfor, she's evil. And therfor, she doesn't love him. And therfor, no baby making.

Oh, I understand now. She didn't flinch because she didn't want to show she didn't care because she doesn't want Eragon to know that she really cares that's why. But at the end she does come near him and speaks with him.

YEEEEESSSSS!!!!!! THANK YOU!!! you finally get it!

NO HE DOESN'T! HE KNOWS THE PART, BUT SHE COULD HAVE STILL MOVED! A FRIEND WOULD MOVE! IF MOVING WOULD SHOW THAT SHE LOVED HIM, THEN YOU JUST PROVED NASUADA HUGGING ERAGON SHOWS LOVE!

A friend WOULD move. We know that Arya is his friend, but she DIDN'T MOVE, which means that she was over-restraining her fellings. she let nothing out, keeping back even what a friend would show because she was afraid of showing her true feelings of love for him.

BUT IT ALSO PROVES SHE'S EVIL!!! SHE WAS COUGHT OFF GUARD BECAUSE THE PLAN TO GET HIM KILLED FAILED!

AND I THINK NASUADA WAS SHOWING WAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAY MORE THEN FRIENDSHIP! SHE JUST RAN AT HIM WITHOUT A WORD! ARYA WOULD HAVE DONE SOMETHING! SHE'S NOT A MORON! IF SHE DID LOVE HIM, SHE WOULD AT LEAST HAVE GOTTEN UP!

I agree if nasanda who is not as close to eragon as arya is got up and huged him shows that ayra is afraid of her true feelings for eragon wich is why she did nothing. shes afirad just like oromis said back in elesmera(sry spell).

So...you all just like not reading then? She was scared in Ellesmera because she was distracting Eragon from his training. She wasn't scared because she liked Eragon. THAT's what Orromis said.

you are DERANGED!!! she is NOT evil!!! AND you are wrong about something else: the plan was to CAPTURE him!!! not to KILL him!!!

And she ISN'T a moron, but hiding her feelings doesn't make her a moron! And she WAS standing, or else when she approached Eragon, CP would have said she got up, then walked over. he didn't.

Whoops! She was never sitting. She was standing by the table. I forgot that. But she still didn't move.

and i explained y.

She still would have moved. She didn't move. She doesn't love him.

elves are masters at hiding their feelings.

Ok i think that a lot would have to happen for them to have a child in the third book. considering everything elese that still has yet to happen i dont think there will be enough time for them to have a child.it seems lik that would be moving to fast, and unless its at the very end i doubt the will have time to have a kid. But i could see them toghter by the end

I think that she loves him, but she doesn't show it

I agree, she loves him but doesn't show it on account of I don't know.

uhuh! if i had a choice between Harry Potter #7 and book #3, i'd choose book #3!

She...does...not...love...him. It is blatently clear, she...does...not...love...him. She said it herself, she...does...not...love...him. How could you need more then, she...does...not...love him? Not deep down, not at all. Not in the future. Not now. Not in her heart. Not in her shoes. Arya...does...not...in...any...way...shape...or...form...love...Eragon...or...even...really...like...him...that...much.

When and where did she say she did not love him?

She said it like, 10 times in the AL. Not to mention when she told him the Menoa Tree story.

she said it ONCE. she told him to back off like 3-4 times, but that has nothing to do with love. it is her duty not to distract Eragon. and what you say about Arya not loveing Eragon even deep down and never will is a mere guess. the difference between my guess and urs is that urs is on unstable ground, because she could have been telling a 1/2 truth, or merely not realizing her love and not knowing about it.

Then how the heck is your ground any stabler?

cuz i have thicker unstable ground, and the cracks overlap. you only have one layer. hmm....which is more unstable???

What are ya'll talking about?

how sound our theories are, but ur right. we should get back on topic.