Eragon WOULD be angry with Saphira. She would have been keeping a part of Eragon's Identity from him, something which he has been desperately trying to grasp.

True about the identity part but, I still say that Eragon would understand and except it as well. I don't think he would get angry or even furious with her because they know each other and they trust each other a lot. He wants to try and find more about who he is and stuff but, like I said Saphira may think that it is not the right time, or whatever, to tell him and if she could explain and everything Eragon would understand and whatnot. It's just what I think...

Yeah, but ANYONE would be angry if they were kept in the dark like that!!! I KNOW I would!!!

Saphire might be keeping things from Eragon but she is only to tell him things when neccasary thats what she said she would do to Brom and a dragon promise isnt broken easily especially if the information can hurt the person. Eragon is one of those people who does sulk. I mean he had to come to terms with having a brother who was on the evil side. He also has to come to terms with Roran comming to fight along side him who is upset since Goran died. THey didnt have a great mourning for him so they have that to deal with too. So she does have to keep things until she feels he is ready to deal with it.

Yeah, and she should have realized by know that he's ready. The only 2 reasons are a lack of judgement on her part (which I doubt) or she doesn't know.

Even if he does get mad, he will have to get over it quickly. They still have work to do. Then they can go back to their personal problems. In a book I read, a character said, "It is only once the battle is over that we notice the tightness of our boots or the hunger in our bellies." If Eragon is mad, he will get over it, or will have to get over it, for the greater good.

When he gets back to Ellesmera, he can be mad all he wants!!!

ok one battle is over but that doesnt mean they won the war yet. She might wait until the war is over before telling him his true name. Remember he did find out that Murtzorgh (spelling is probably wrong sorry) is his brother since their mother was Selena. So he still has to come to terms with that.

She doesn't know his true name!!! What people are trying to say that she knows is that Eragon is the son of Brom!!! That's what I meant by identity!

ok but dont forget that Murzon had a son with Selena so we know that He is the father of Eragon. the only different between Eragon and Murtzorgh (spelling?) is that Eragon grew up knowing right from wrong. And Murtzorgh was always under the influence of his father and the king. I mean Gaby did have him brougth to the castle to live so he was always on the fence until the egg hatched. Especially since Brom already was in Caverhall when Selena came there pregnant

That's what CP wants you to think. Ive got the evidence!!!! Here it goes: Brom said, “She was full of dignity and pride, like Garrow. Ultimately it was her downfall, but it was one of her greatest gifts nevertheless. . . . She always helped the poor and the less fortunate, no matter what her situation.” He answered to Eragon’s question, “You knew her well?”, “Well enough to miss her when she was gone.” Also, Blagden said “Son and father alike, both as blind as bats” after being asked what his first prophesy ment. This denotes that Blagden had met Eragon's father. Morzan had never gone to Ellesmera, though Brom had. On pg. 435 of Eragon, Angela saya, "He (Brom) loved a woman, but it was his affection which was her undoing." So what happened was she was carrying Brom's child and Morzan found out. She went to Carvahall and had Eragon. She then ran off, running from Morzan, was caught, and then killed. This enraged Brom and Brom went and killed Morzan. Later, he went to Carvahall to keep an eye on his son, Eragon.

And if he is upset he has to stop right away. I don't think he will mind, I would personally be grateful towards her, as well as very happy.

I think that Saphira will tell him everything after he defeats Galbatorix.

After. No, I am doubting that she would tell him everything after. I think that she knows some very important and useful information that Eragon needs to know before fighting and defeating Galby. I doubt she would wait that long either...no whatever she knows and is keeping secret she will tell Eragon before Galby's defeat and whatnot...it will most likely come in handy or something...and Eragon needs to know before the end as well.

ok, what ever you say.

What i'm trying to say is that he will be angry, and he will eventually get over it. He can't give her the silent treatment forever, because forever is a long time for him!!!

Well, he could, but that would get annoying if he was always like, Arya tell saphira i'm still mad at her, when she's right beside him!!!!!!!!

What are you talking about??? That'd be awsome!!!

Too Harry Potterish. They will get over it.

I'd deffinately be P.O.ed!!!

I would be happy that some psycho guy wasn't my father.

Yeah, but I'd be angry that that information was kept from me for so long, even when it could comfort me.

Yeah, but he would be happy. Besides, he has to get over it.

well, he may just scream, adn then get over it who knows?

He HAS to get over it. If him and Saphira can't work together, Alagaesia is lost.

Well, that too but I think that she'd tell him after so he can be mad for as long as he wants.

Why would she do that? He will be shocked and hurt at first, but will get over it.

But then it wouldn't effect the team work at all.

No, he's going to ask Oromis, who'll tell him. Then Saphira would let it slip that she knew and Eragon would be angry. He would be angry for a while, then they would make up.

that's a good idea, but the thing is how would he know who Eragon's father was.

Maybe Saphira told him..... or he just knew....

This would be a sight worth seeing but, rather horrid really. LOL! I doubt it will happen like that though...him screaming or something...nah...not Eragon.





I agree and I know he'll get over it. It's not like Eragon to be mad forever and not forgive or something. But, it's true Alagaesia would be lost, everything would be lost if that happened but, like I said I doubt it...and he'll get over it no matter what. He's a strong guy and he needs to focus and things right now.

Oromis could know. He seemed rather close to Brom.

There's a definite possibility. I bet Oromis does know and knows a lot more than what he is letting on. He was close to Brom and all and seeing he trained Eragon up a bit and whatnot. Plus he's a dragonrider and maybe he knew things right off the bat and whatnot. I think he does know...ohh...thanks for the idea...Oromis must know something.

I know that he does know alot he is tryiing to not take any shortcuts with Eragon while smashing a ton of stuff in his face that he has to learn. I know from experince something like that is hard to do. Ormosis has a Dragon Rider does know alot and is working on teaching Eragon but what if he dies before Eragon gets back? He seemed really weak and getting weaker all the time. How will Eragon find out then. IF you use the Ormosis theory use it with the Saphira theory so that they both know and came to a agreement to tell him when they felt it was needed.

The one thing that we know is that Oromis will die after Eragon goes back to Ellesmera.

Well whatever Oromis knows though that Saphira, and probably a lot of other characters know, I am sure he will tell Eragon before he dies in the book...that's if he knows anything which I believe now that he does and if he dies, which I believe that he will as well. *sniff*

Assisted by Arya! Don't foget her!

CP said that Oromis is going to have a bigger role in book 3 and that wouldn't make any sence if he died as soon a they go back to Ellesmera.

When did he say that??? Yeah, teaching 2 students is a bigger role than teaching 1!!!

Perhaps he will have his role to play, like he did in Eldest as a teacher and guide, then later on somehow he would die. I didn't think he would die directly after Eragon went back to Ellemera either...doesn't make much sense as you have said. He will have a bigger role, that now is obvious and CP has said so but, we all think in some way he will die*sniff*.

Like I said, training 2 riders!

i reckon imnotcrazy is crazy. crazy about Arya that is lol

LOL.. hahha

oromis i think will die in the end of the book cuz thats what usually happens in books these days.

More like middle-end. he'll die right before Eragon goes off to beat Galbatorix.

nah im thinking after the big battle.. oromis might go into battle and die and the end of the battle.. kinda like ajhad ( sp)

Ajhad died at the beginning of the book. Brom died in the middle, and Garrow in the beginning. From the other deaths, it seems like it won't be at the very end.

Maybe CP wants to shake things up.

i think eraGON will go to ellesmera and oromis wud die ther cos of his illness

i think eraGON will go to ellesmera and oromis wud die ther cos of his illness

no im saying like ajihad died at the end of the battle..

AFTER his training. he can't battle Murtagh without more training!

Eragon said he could beat him if he wasn't so tired.

ya he can he will just get beat again.. lol but still hes gona go to the vault of souls before he fights murtagh or galbatorix

He can beat Murtagh. Not so sure about Galbatorix.

eragon thinks he cud beat him at sword fighting not at magic if he wos rested

actully if he can kill murtagh he can certintly kill galbatorix cuz he is as strong as galbatorix..

No, Murtagh said that no one could beat him but Galbatorix himself.

yeahbut its close and murtaghs probably better than galby at swordfightin cos galbys and old man

yeah, but Galbatorix is getting stronger every day!!!

so is murtagh and he is still mostlikley as strong if not stronger then galbatorix cuz galbatorix tought him all his secrets and murtagh is younger then him.. soo

He probably didn't teach him EVERYTHING!!! That and Galbatorix has been growing stronger for near 100 years!!! He is WAY stronger than Murtagh.

We actually dont know how strong Galabatrix anymore, we know that he WAS really powerfull but he COULD be as crippled as Oromis!

i doubt he wud b crippled else how wud he do that spell that disguises his army moving towards surda and even the elves didn't break it for a while

Besides, Murtagh himself said that Galbatorix was stronger than him.

hm...maybe, galbatorix strenth isn't as great as it used to be? Somewhere was said that he used to fly around in alagaesia but now he stays in uru'baen most of the time. maybe, that indicates that he's getting weaker or something.

just a theorie, though.

i think hes jusat lazy

I agree. He's just really lazy!!!

Yeah me too, he is so lazy. Another reason why he hasen't told murtagh everything he knows yet is probably becuse he dosen't want murtagh to have powers that could match his, or even over throw him.

Maybe he is not that powerful. Oromis said that much of Galbatorix's power comes from an image of invincibility.

No, because he could still live forever. We have no records of Galbatorix being injured and needing something to sustain himself.

i doubt that as he goes to dras leona in Eragon so he be able to depend on anything unless he took it withhim

Isn't he taking his powers from his surroundings? I mean, he dosn't really care if he kills his sources. Maybe, he has perfectionated (is that a word?) this way of gaining strenght. He is also a master of breaking into peoples minds, so he can have sources of strenght practically all over alagaesia.

he cud do that especially if he only takes energy from people in the city who can withstand the spell

I doubt that's the source of his power, but we will find out.

You said he would die if his power source were removed. Riders can't die unless blade or poison takes them.

I heard some one say that he was getting his powers from the vault of souls, that would also explain that when Eragon touched murtagh's mind why he felt multipul souls.

That could make sense..... hmm.....

Yaeh, we know. That's why you are here.

lol

I have to say this: don't spam. So, what do you think Saphira knows?

Alot but not as much a we think

i don't remember reading that, i'll check on that......ok, your right! that could be a huge possibility

i doubt she knows his real name brom said that riders would go on quests to find their name or ask an elf. but i bet saphira knows a lot more than shes telling . she may if brom is his father. and possibly have seen broms memorys.

yeah he should do that

Mabey, Eragon's name is a word lost to the AL and it has a powerfull meaning. Idk, it's just a random thought.

maybe eragons AL name is shared with the original eragon o-o