sorry but she looks terrible
come on, she looks like a mix between mary jane and the witch from Narnia or something

I agree, she's awful! Plus she looks like a teenager not an ageless elf with the wisdom of 70 yrs, plus she looks blond. Did they not read the book? I thought it was clear something about midnight hair. blah!

actually it looks more redish like a cross between mary jane and the witch in narnia she almost looks a little older

in the video game she is a good fighter in clips( thats all the show her in) i hope she is in the movie, and if she is just a loser that runs around with swords i'll be laughing and angry at the same time.

oh my gosh! the actress that plays arya ia really good and qualified and stuff but shes not the right look to put it kindly.i mean i seriously look more like the arya in the books more than she does!i have black hair, green eyes, im tall, and strong, and could so play this part!!!!





shiek ^.^

she looks like... a british model which is what she is

Actually really liked her. Considering Sienna is thirty something years old and playing this role she does portray a 70 year old youthful looking elf. Yeah, they changed some things, but it is not the actresses fault. I kind of like the fact that she has red hair, in my opinion the red hair made her seem more like an elf in my opinion. Ok now you can all bite my head off for actually liking Arya.

I thought she was good... I liked her eyes mostly- and there was a mystical "air" about her that I liked... but she didn't have pointy ears and black hair ;_;

What the heck is an elf without pointed ears?! I mean SERIOUSLY! that is not cool! sorry... went a little postal there... but she looks like nothing in the book makes me sad. oh well. and I thought she was supposed to have black hair.

i thinks shes a really good actor so don,t be mean.

Yeah, Sienna is awesome. She the Arya for me - but id prefer her with the black hair, elf ears and proper clothing (leather pants and skirt) rather than an off the shoulder stop. What she wore in the final battle was good except who where's a skirt in battle?

I also like her in the book better, her appearance may have been a mary-sue but her personality was far from it. In the movie she was more like a character out of a chick flick - but either way that's nothing to do with Sienna guillory, she was just playing a role.

in the film shes ugly. but in the book i imagened her really pretty like elves are ment to look like.i like the book more than the film.

I thought Ayra was pretty... I loved how expressive her eyes were.

Sienna was good. The script writers were bad. Think about it she was definite attractive and had nice eyes. So if you just dyed her hair black, gave her elf ears and leather pants and shirt, you would see she was perfect.

I think the movies just portrayed her terribly, but how is that the actor fault?

edit by rpm: added your username

I havent seen the movie but the preview for it kind of upset me because I like to picture what everything looks like while I read and when I saw Arya I was pretty mad... come on now I look more like what she was described as then she did... Ill still see the movie though... i guess

I think as an actress she did very well and played the script she was given without much fault...The script writers though...grrr. I dont know wether its just me but Arya came across (at least in the first book) very cold and although she warms up a bit she's never REALLY friendly like she is in the movie. Does any one agree?

And what is up with the skirt? lol

arya wasn't how i imagined her, but what i disliked the most was that they didn't really show how good a fighter she was and how strong, fast, etc. she was

i agree the lady that plays arya is a pretty good actress and that was one of the good pionts in the movie other than messing up alot of the scenes

well i think she's pretty good ,they choose the right person , she's a nice actress

She's a good actress but her character was screwed up. Arya was nothing like she was described in the book and if you ask me, if in the movie your not going to stick to a lot of stuff in a very popular book read by millions, you shouldn't make it.

i couldn't agree more!! i've ranted so much about this, but at the core of the issue is the fact that they could have afforded to shell out a little more dough to make the movie more accurate, longer, ect and more accepted by the millions of ppl who read the books and love them!!!

she is so terrible i hate eragon the movie

she looked so different but stop insulting the actress its not her fault

Yeah I mean she was okay but she could of been better. But for the most part she played the role well. And it kinda looked like she a had a thing for Eragon.

They soooooooooooooooo messed her up! She's an ELF not a HUMAN!!!!!!!!!

I haven't seen the movie but from pics Arya looks like a medevial knight ! not a beautiful elf like she should be!!!

I think its horrible that they bad her a blonde! I mean COME ON!! She is supposed to be an elf with black hair! I haven't seen the movie but I don't even think her ears are pointed! They should have stuck to the original character, not this version.