Okey... Me being me, I just love to discus and argue over such things.
And plus that I have a strong opinion in this ;D ;D

So what do you guys thinks? Is Lily where she should been or should she have been with Snape?

And I will start with being quite blunt! The LilyxSnape parring is nothing but a pity for Snape. Some people read the few pages in the Deathly Hallows and became "Nawww!!! That is so sad! He deserves some love!" And poff! Serval HP fans has made their own OOC characters and convinced them self that they are right when thinking LilyxSnape is "true love" and all that crap <__<

And I even question if Snape really loved Lily.
I call it obsession and not love. Why? because it was obsession!

All he wanted was that she should be his.
If he truly would have loved her, he would have cared for her. Not alone wanting her. He didn't cared for her feelings. Lily had two persons who she loved more than her own life. Snape didn't gave a $hit about if Harry and James. He just wanted her and gave no second thoughts on what she felt. It was like, who care if James and Harry dies? Who cares if she breaks down over it as long as I get her?
As Dumbledore him self said to it. "It sickens me"
Lilys life was James and Harry. Snape didn't cared as long as he could claim her. And that selfish git didn't changed that until it actually hurt him self. He didn't cared until he felt the pain himself. He first changed when she died. When his obsession became a longing.

And some people thinks that Snape is juts misunderstood. He is not. He was quite bad in the beginning(close to being evil)
Snape had his views on muggles and muggle born. And it was not the good ones. He agreed with Voldemort and the death eaters.
That he cared for one muggle born don't makes up for his view on the others and it would never justify anything either. And rember that it was he alone who took away the friendship with Lily. It wasn't just the calling "mudblood" As Lily her self said after that sadly part, she was tired of making up excuses for him. She stood up and protected him due to their friendship. But he made his own choices and they ended up as it did.

Snape was prior Hogwarts all Slyherin. He wanted to be there and made his own friends there. (aka. the other deatheaters) Snape made his own choices freely because of his opinion. That he though well of one mudblood do not justify anything.

And you don't just join Voldemort for fun or protection. You work for him.
It's only to be expected that Snape has killed, tortured and destroyed families. Snape would by all means be horrible and wrong with Lily.
Lily and James was meant to be. There was real love between them.

Snape as Harry's father? 0__O How can that grease git be the father to Harry even in a fanfiction when Harry is almost a perfect copy of James? 0__O
It makes no sense <__< And just the thought of that any one actually would do "it" with Snape is a disturbing thought xD xD

Serveus Snape was a man who:

* Bullied and hated a little boy due to being a rival to the boys father.
* Favors students even tho that he is a teacher.
* Bullies and struck down on students he personally don't like.
* Looks down on muggleborns (expect one)
* Refuses to even listen to facts when an old rivalry comes back.
* Creates dark spells and are obsessed with dark arts.
* Gives no sympathy
* Served Lord Voldermort willingly for years.
* Bullies muggleborns. (Hermione in particular)


And by J.K's own writing has sallow skin, a large, hooked nose, and yellow, uneven teeth. Has shoulder-length, greasy black hair which frames his face, and cold, black eyes. He wears black, flowing robes which give him the appearance of "an overgrown bat"

I would get nightmares if I ever would read them. Just the idea of it is something I find disgusting <__<


That is actually quite common.
But a thing that isn't would be that your son would be a copy of your own enemy/school rival. The DNA would prevent it. Because it is based on your parents.


Same thing for my best friend and her mother ;D They also only have different eyes colors xD


caterpillar! That is horrible and highly OOC! D:


I don't want to think about it either D: D:

I'm sure that the brain bleach will return soon Saph ^^

Hmm... Do you chose Snape for the reason of being a rebel or can you actually see that grease git with some one?


Do you look alike or are you close in age?