Does anyone think that murtagh is a shade, or do they just think galabatrix made him as strong as he is... How?

HEs a Rider turned into a shade!!!!!! I'm sticking to that theory...

It could be I just dont think that it just sounds like something CP would have brought to our attention if it happened.

i highly doubt murtagh is a shade... he just learned galbatorix secret of how he keeps gettign stronger.. and also when he was fighting eragon he said he learned was to manipulate energy

he would have been even more powerful if he was a shade

not neccisarilly...remember in Eldest when he was fighting Vanir,he said he was just as good a any magical creature or Shade sense he turned into an Elf/Human.

Vanir owns

Eregon is as strong as any magical creature and Murtagh did match up to his swordsmanship as an elf/human. I dont think that Murtagh is a shade, some said earlier that galabatrix did teach him how to manipulate energy but that has nothing to do with how outstanding his swordsmanship abilities are for a human

ya thats why we are talking about his magical power.. not swordmanship cuz they are both evenly matched.. even after eragon is very tired from battleing all day w/o a break and he still almost beats murtagh..

I know but how do you think Murtagh is such a good sward fighter, because even if Eregon is very tired he could probably beat a very good human swardsmen no problem

well in the second one when the fought practicing they were evenly matched.. but now he would be able to beat him easly

But they did dual at the end of the empire and he wasnt beat easily

at the end of empire what??

i think he ment eldest

oh well if u meant eldest murtagh wasnt easly defeated because eragon was tired from fighting all day during the last battle remember? he hadnt took a break all day and he was still evenly matched for a while with murtagh

sorry about that I was thinking of Eldest

oh.. k well i posted it on last page