i thought that it was interesting that nasuada was willing to allow the urgals fight along side them. i never thought that this would even happen in the first place! does everyone think that she made the right choice would you have let them if you were her?

Yeah, why not?

Every army needs some big bruisers to knock a hole enemy line or whatever.
And, if your taking on the whole empire, you're going to need all the help you can get.

i think yes, because she needed the urgals and because i believe they were honest when they said to want fight Galbatorix

oh yes she was definitely right to allow them to fight with her how else would they have gotten the better of the battle with out the extra help??

I think she was right because they really needed the help and there was no other way they could have survived the battle.
Besides Eragon probley would have been dead because he would have had to use that much more magic and also be more suvaliant (is that a word?) about the people around him because he would have had less people protecting him. Nasuda might be dead too. But that is a streach.

Of course it was a GOOD choice. There is always a free spot in first line...

well the reason why i was wondering was because eragon threw his little fit about having to fight next to them that way i was wondering if any one agrred with him or not

Yeah that empty headed racist... I hate him for it I can imagine how many problems could the urgals cause but that is no reason to refuse their help...

I can understand how he felt though.

Its like having someone murder your brother and best friends and leaders and then having to work with them. Besides Eragon didnt know that the Urgals were under a spell or whatever it was that kept them bound. He thought that they were acting of there own free will and enjoying it.

i can see why he did not want them cuz i probably would not want them next to me either but im sorry i would rather one of them die then eragon or nausada, anyone along those lines

i think she risked quite alot with everybodys dislike of them

i think she did the right thing, because Urgals are actually good creatures, humans just invaded their land, so they fought back, and they fought the Varden because of Durza. But yes, she did take a risk as seen in Brisingr.