I think that it should be Thorn. I believe Thorn is not evil. He just hatched at the wrong place and at the wrong time. Anyway the reason why is because I thought something wonderful might happen if they do get together. The simple fact is that I think that it was basically the Vardens fault that Surda was attacked, see my point? Later on, the green dragon can mate with their daughter. By the time Eragon said to let Murtagh kill him and Thorn, that was kinda selfish because there is always another way to free someone from a spell. Though I'm not trying to criticise the story and all. I also thought that if Saphira and Thorn learn to understand one another, they would probably jump into the middle of a fight between their riders and tell them to stop because that is where the path to hatred as brought them. Then not only Eragon and Murtagh will stop fighting, but also the war will end faster. The empire will betray Galbatorix and join the Varden instead. Knowing that they are all one. Eragon and Arya will later fall in love including Murtagh and Nasuada. Then in Eragons' dream Saphira and the other dragon will leave with him and Arya. I pictured it to be Thorn because I thought Izlandi would punish Murtagh and Thorn by somehow removing the bond between them. Thorn will say goodbye to Murtagh and promises to meet him another time. That is why I believe Thorn and Saphira should get together. Well, what do you think of that theory. Do you agree or disagree?

Both i agree because...it would explain so much if thorn was saphira's
mate... and because it was selfish that eragon asked that.......
but i disagree because...why would Izlandi punish them for being force to agree to something in al ....and even if Izlandi punished them she probley wouldn't go so far that it removed their bond with each other
and thats about it

I don't think so. Because Saphira never said that it would affect those who share the same blood. For example, Saphira fell in love with Glaedr but I don't see Eragon sharing the same feelings towards Oromis.

i think that there's a slim chance that they could mate, but first she would have to get over the contempt that eragon feels for them. since he is closer to her age, that might be the only possible mate.

uh... who cares? Thorn mating with Saphira is what we call in the shipping business CRACK. It's NOT going to happen. They are on opposing sides and that is not likely to change.

The third egg hatches for Galby? This guys on a roll LOL But good job there. . . . I actually thought you had nothing for a moment....