What do you think Eragons quandary is?

i personally think the last egg is in Helgrind and he has to choose between saving Roran and Katrina or saving the egg.

what do you think?

what "quandary"? what are you talking about? why would there BE a quandary???

I think he means situation. He's asking if Eragon will face a decision between saving Katrina and saving the last egg.

But wot will he choose? he could choose to save the egg but save Katrina 2.... i think its a very good question. i dont think he'll get out of Helgrind if he doesnt save her as Roran wont let him, or Roran can save Katrina whilst Eragon finds the egg.... maybe.... kinda.....sort of.....

Saphira could save the egg and Eragon could save Katrina
they are two seprate beings...

yea but Roran is going to n he would more likely save Katrina. plus i think Eragon and Saphira will have enough problems fighting the Raz'zac

Yea Eragon and Saphira do all the hard work killing and fighting them and Roran runs and sobs over Katrina. Feeling sorry for himself and promising empty promises to her. How heroic of Roran...
lol

I highly doubt there's going to BE a quandary of that sort.

i think Roran will kill the ra'zac or die trying
personally i think Roran will die in book 3 in the fight between him and the Raz'ac, but i think the Raz'ac kidnapped katrine, WHICH would have started the fight
which in turn would bring eragon to the Raz'ac, which is what they wanted all along: KATRINA would be the bate, Roran and Eragon would follow after





BUT that is JUST a THEORY

Its a good one too, except that I don't think Roran would die. Think about how upset Eragon would get...he'll probably forget all about the egg XD

mayb...

I think it's a possibility that that situstion may come up. If it does, I think he will first save Katrina, then capture the egg. That's kinda what he did in book one: he saved Arya, then fought Durza. He saves the girl first, then does his unexpected duty. It's just the way he does things. . .

same here