I think Roran and Eragon or Arya and Eragon will storm the castle while the other person tries to lure the Ra'zac away and they'll rescue Katrina. And they'll find the egg being guarded well by Urgals, Soldiers, and maybe one Ra'zac.

That's what I'm talking about.

The urgals are on the side of the Varden now.

Thta's true, but the others aren't helping Galbatorix anymore!!!

fyi, uhh..... Kull ARE Urgals.

The urgals (including Kull) aren't helping Galbatorix.

Yup, that's about right!!! You are right about something! YAY!

Oh I hate not having my book! I'MNOTCRAZY if you have your copu of Eldest, can you pls look up the chapter on the battle. I cannot remember if other Kulls fought on Galbatorix's side.
What I do remember when were being persecuted after they left the Hadarac, Murtagh told Eragon that the Kulls were the elite of the Urgals. There were huge and about 8 feet tall and no horse could carry them. They were fast on their feet and could go days without food or rest.

There were no Urgals fighting with the Empire. As for Arya going with Eragon to the Helgrind, I don't see a way that CP will give her a good reason to go with him. It isn't the same thing because Murtagh helped save her. This is revenge in which she has no part.

Yeah there is no reason for her to go with Eragon to Helgrind. But there is for Roran, Katrina.

But then Eragon is going to find the egg, if and only if it's there, which it's probably not, and he will give it to Arya to take care of like she did Saphira, and it will hatch for her.

There is no good reason why Roran should be picked. I discredited all of them.

or the elf rider could be vanir, who feels bad about taunting eragon

Yeah, did you ever think of that???

how do you know that arya is going

ya their gona fall over dead and then the elves are gona b like noooooooo.. then they will get barried

It is the only way to maintain balence, and the only way to beat Galbatorix. Roran wouldn't stand a chance. There isn't enough time to train him. Besides, he would never be as powerful as Arya is anyways.

But Oromis is the Elf rider and then it will be two humans versus two humans, it'll be equal.

and im still betting on vanir

No, because Oromis is going to die. Besides, the good side needs an advantage, namely Arya.

Roran can be an advantage like he killed those Twins with his axe. He did pretty good with them.

Thta was a hammer. He is not proficient enough in ANYTHING to be much of a help and even if he could have all the time in the world to train, which he doesn't, he will never be as powerful as Arya.

Because elves are very skilled but he could always get better and be as good as Eragon at least.

Eragon is as good as the most athletic elf now.

Kind of. They share the change that the Dragons have done to the Elven race. They still have their differeces, but only those differences which the Elves and Humans had before the bonding with the Dragons.

Yeah, but he's going to have to wait another century. My point: It's not going to happen!!!

roran won't be changed, and therefore, he won't be rider

He doesn't need arya, she can still join the battle and be with him, I'm just saying it might be Roran.

Great point!!! ARYA'S GOING TO BE THE NEXT RIDER WHETHER YOU LIKE IT OR NOT!!!

Why'd you say I had a great point? Then say Arya's going to be the next rider. She may or may not. I still say it's going to be Roran.

You psted yours a second before I posted mine. So i was talking to Dragon_lover.

Oh ok. But that post still says what I feel that Roran should be Rider.

Well, you are wrong!!! GET OVER IT!!!

if imnotcrazy and everyone else drops who they think the next rider is, and stops talking about, i will drop the vanir thing

I don't mind you thinking it's Vanir because I have no clue how he'll become it but if I'MNOTCRAZY will stop and Anniebee then I will too. Also the chick I'MNOTCRAZY likes.

who does IMNOTCRAZY like??

ok well anniebee is a mom.. ( not meaning anything ) and glaedr94 is a guy.. lol and you just asked me if i was a girl in the other topic and ur using purple font,..

oh the one w/ the pic of glaedr in his/her sig??

oh holly? hmm her sn thing is Dragon_lover.. but idk if he likes her.. are you making this stuff up??

LMAO!!! No, i don't have a crush on anybody here!!! lol!

IM STILL LMAO!!!

Laughing my @$$ off.

come on!!! How stupid can you be!!!

Nah, they're just being stupid.

hey... i never said he liked any1 i was just telling him the name of the person HE thoug hyou liked....

AnnieBee, calm down. This topic is so vague that it is hard NOT to get off topic!!!

Believe or not, I am calm, and annoyed 19 posts which has nothing to do with Book 3.

I truly believe Nasuada would be an excellent candidate to rule the new Alagaesia. Once Alagaesia is freed from the menance of Galbatorix and his minions, the Varden may disperse within the country and begin living once more.

I don't know. It seems reasonable, but anything is possible.

Well the only answer to this my friend, is that she will die a PAINFULL HORRIBLE death

nahh.. that will never happen.. your idea is to farfetched.. pshh her queen?? yay right

It just depends on what path Nasuada chooses to take. She is by far the best leader I have seen since she is basically taking care of the Carden and whatnot. She has all the qualities of a ruler and the duty would suit her. But it just depends on what she wants to do in her life and where she decides to go...after all ruling may not be her destiny but I think it's a great thought.

If Nasuada dies Roran wont rule he has no leadership experience on a large scale basis and really quite honestly would insufficiantly rule algaesia.

WOW! Well said. I think if Roran is planning on being a leader of any kind it will be the army type thing. He'd make a great commander/general. Yeah he just doesn't seem like the person to rule Alagaesia, too much responsibility and I don't think he's got the guts and he's not as wise as Nasuada to be ruling a whole empire and whatnot.

Nasuada moved the entire Varden to Surda!!! That counts for A LOT MORE!!!