ik that Eragon pleged his allegiance to Nasuada...but do you think he could turn bad? I mean he could break it.

no way, he is the hero. Its stupid to even mention it

Eragon, evil??? He won't even eat a rabbit, or even harm a fly (and I mean that literally) But in battle, ruthless.

i agree with katerna

he shouldn't made any vow to nasuada at the first place, but @ that time, it was needed.
No, i don't think he would break his oath... as long as nasuada be on the right track with the good side, it is.

i know he will not whether or not he can is beyond me

only way he would break the vow is if nasuada turned bad

only way he would break the vow is if nasuada turned bad, which wont happen

that's wut i mean

ya neva know

It wouldn't make any sense for eragon to turn bad. It just won't happen.

eragon wont turn bad, he will break his oath if nasuada turns bad, eragon will stay good. (nasuada will never go bad...no chance in hell, id give odds a billion to one)

Hmmm . . . 2/3 riders evil? What a message to send to the children. Much more than that, very unlikely.

Saphira would never allow it. She has too much honor. And how would this come about? Eragon taking a permanent leave of his senses?

I shouldn't bash this too much, because with all the twists in this series it may happen. or, it may be part of an elaborate plan to defeat Galbatorix.

Well, a good twist would be to have Eragon turn bad, Murtagh defeat him and Galbatorix, and have Murtagh be the one who inherits.

Likely? No.

Nasuada will not turn evil! Sure she turns to Urgals for help but unless Galbortorix, himself, puts a powerful spell over the two of them, 99.9 % unlikely that they will turn evil.

well--nasuada may never turn evil, but she might did wrong movement or false step.... the one that she thought is d'right thing to do, but eragon thought otherways. Would eragon not obey her, if that happen?? u know, like something with the urgals-aliances, but in this case just say it... worse.

He made an oath to her in the anceint language so he can't break it and even if he did(somhow idk how he could do it) saphira like she said would capture him and hold him prisoner.

Yea I don't know about Eragon but there is no way in hell that Saphira would turn evil.

caterpillar, how stupid must u b 2 suggest that saphira wud let eragon turn evil? unless galby put him under a spell

dont think that would happen, Eragon is the hero. forever and ever. and ever and ever and ever and ever and ever and ever and ever....getting the point?

For ever and ever Amen! lol

you don't turn the main charecter bad, he is the one its about.

I agree that eragon will NEVER turn bad, but sometimes it adds an interesting twist to a story!

Fans like us would get together with fire and chase CP if he made Eragon go evil...or die for that matter... the first one is worse though.

I like fire- he'd better not turn evil though!

hmm, 'fire'tounge like fire, hmm, is it just me or do other people thing that is redundent?


and i would also grab a pitch fork to chase him.

eragon will never become evil

but he may die. there are many books where the main character dies after a very harsh battle ofr something of that.

i dont think he will die, and i agree with glenwing about the hero thing

if any one die i would most likely think it nausada or roran. and i'm not sure 'bout those. but the elf teacher, 'the cripple who is hole' might and probally will die in book 3.

ya, agreed

and i dont think any other ones would die. if they die then it not so great book. sure, let nausada folo her father!

there is no way eragon will turn bad

if he does i am going to make a whole thread on this puppy aobut not to buy it becuase it suks.

if eragon turns bad, it will b like star wars far too much

"Never underestimate the power of the dark side" (said wit all the funny breathin fx of darth vader)

[quote="Glenwing"]no way, he is the hero. Its stupid to even mention it[/quote]

Eragon EVIL, noway

then why would he kill galby if he is evil

it would be starwars, except eragon was not 9 or 10 in the begining.

the series would suck if it turned star wars style

ya, becuase there go Eragon, hes choking arya with magic. (anakin choke padme, and they were married)

and then aryas mom is all like dont shoke my daughter and turns execution style and chops eragons head off

LOL, she might be able to kill him, but she might need other elves to

while arya tries to escape aryas mom catches eragon by suprise

eragon spreads out his mind.

ya but then arya would be attaking it

oh ya... ok you got me there. i can't figure out a way he could.

i know too much about eragon for u to trick me

Lol

Star Wars!!!!!
Yeah he will turn bad but before it he will...ehm ok he will have a son with Arya and son will kill him when grows

NO NO NO NO NO. HE WILL NOT.

yea first of all that would take to long to stuff with every thing else in the book second of all thats just dumb

lol

wats so funny

incomer and erais. and i thought people were after me for spammin'... not that i really ment to...

then stop spamming

i'm not, i am no longer using just one word, i'm not even using abreavation for laughing out loud on this forum ever agian.

well lol is a good abrivation for that long thing just like Lmao is which mean Laughing my ass off

i know, i jsut got bugged into saying i won't say it, so im writing it out, on this forum at leazt

(i like z)

well no one will blame u for putting lol because its really long

well no one will blame u for putting lol because its really long

if eragon does become bad, that could be why he has to leave alagaesia .

hmm, good theory. i cna't think of a way to twist that one

i can, he won't leave alagaesia if he is bad becuase he would stay and rule alagaesia

aha, good one! but if he is bad then the next DR would kill him, or Arya would, or sum other elf would

no he would be even stronger than galby haha

Nay that would defeat the purpose of the series. But anyway to defeat Gably he may need to tap into forbidden magic, exiling himself from the world when he believes that he may turn into what Gably was.

u talk as if u were ancient man and i think the magic part is where the vault of souls comes in

NO WAY

Nasuada could die but Eragon going evil???
It would ruin everything!!!
ANd the switch around idea that would be like taming of the shrew!!
I hate that play.
Eragon will kill Galby, free Murtagh and then something terrible will happen forcing him to leave...
i think...

No, I do not think so. Eragon is porteayed as much too honorable to do so.

Very interesting.. very interesting. You mean like beeing exiled?? That possible. But... who will confront a mighty rider and strong enough to make him leave alagaesia??

He had to leave alagaesia by his own will, I guess..

impossible eragon the hero

i think we all know he won't become a vilian so i think we can lock this topic

I AGREE!!!

I think this is an interesting topic, with lots of good theories, so I'm not locking it unless whoever made it asks to have it locked.

no wants to lock the topic

Good point, maybe Oromis will have to tell him the things & spells he wanted to remain lost or forgotten!

the elves know black magic but they don't say it

tell were u found that one

yea, i mean if anyone it woudl be Oromis who knew them, and he can barely do the simple stuff! and about lockin', i geuss you'll have to get Nazuada to ask Firetongue, Eragon109/AnnieBee

wat do u mean and y is my name in there is it because i know a lot of the mods

Why ask me? I'm just clarifying the posts that are WORTH clarifying; so many ridiculous ideas are posted here that it makes me wonder if I read the same book as these people. And English is not even my first language. I know that Eragon cannot die, he will go through hell and back before he is victorious, but he will not die.

i wan't asking u i was asking durza killer

PEACE!
And I was not refering the post to you. I was also asking Durza Killer, because MY NAME is also on the post; AND I just commented on many people who post erronous facts about the stories without even checking the facts. They are the ones who come up on the board as ignorants. So no, I was not talking about you. So don't snap at me!


And NO, NO, NO! Eragon will not die! LONG LIVE ERAGON!

ok, ok, if everyone wants it locked, so be it. But I'm not to be held responsible if it annoys people...